æãèŠãæž
ã什åïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥
ãïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒ
å µåº«çå·è¥¿åžç«æïŒäžç®ïŒïŒçªïŒïŒå·
äžè¬è²¡å£æ³äººãåœéçŠç¥äººæš©ç 究財å£
代衚çäºãéšè°·åº·åŒ
ïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒ-ïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒ
ãïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒ
æ±äº¬éœäžå€®åºæ¥æ¬æ©è å Žçº3äžç®9çª10å·
å ¬ç瀟å£æ³äººãåäºæ³åç 究äŒã家ææ³ç 究äŒã埡äž
ïŒç 究調æ»éšãïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒ
åæž
代衚çäºã§ããæèŠè ã§ããéšè°·åº·åŒã¯ïŒå¿çã«ãŠã³ã»ã©ãŒãšã°ãªãŒãã±ã¢ã¢ããã€ã¶ãŒã®è¬ç¿ãä¿®äºããæè³æ Œè ã§ããããŸãåã©ãã®çŠç¥ã«é¢ããã»ãããŒã«ç©æ¥µçã«åå ãïŒæ§ã ã«æ å ±åéãšæèŠäº€æãéããŠãããããã§ïŒåã©ãã®çºéïŒèåŸ ãäœçœ°ïŒé害ïŒãã©ãŠãïŒç芪çå€ïŒãããŠèŠªåäžåé¢ã®ååãšïŒèŠªååçµ±åïŒèŠªåæ§ç¯ïŒã®æå¹æ§ã€ããŠå°éæ§ãæããŠããç«å Žã«ããããšãèžãŸãïŒèŠªæš©ãšç£è·æš©åã³åã®ç£è·è«æ±ïŒé©æ£æªçœ®è«æ±ïŒåŠšå®³æé€è«æ±ïŒæš©ãšå ±ã«èå¯ãïŒåã®æåã®å©çã«è³ããå®åéçšã®éèŠãã€å¿ èŠãªåçççç±ã«ã€ãæèŠããã
ïŒåã®è«æ±æš©ãšèŠªã®ä»£çæš©ïŒ
æèŠã®è¶£æš
ïŒïŒåã®è«æ±æš©ã«ã€ãïŒé芪暩è 芪ïŒèŠªå¯ãªçŽç³»è¡æïŒã«åã®ä»£çæš©ãèšããã¹ããåŠãæèŠããã
ïŒïŒåã®è«æ±æš©ã«ã€ãïŒèªå·±æ±ºå®ïŒæèŠè¡šæïŒã®è©äŸ¡åºæºãïŒïŒæãšããŠèšããã¹ããåŠãæèŠããã
æèŠã®äºç±
ïŒïŒåã®ä»£çæš©ã¯é芪暩è 芪ïŒä»¥äžé芪暩è ïŒã«èšããã¹ããåŠãã®æ€èš
ã¢ïŒæé«è£äºå°æ±ºæåïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒæ¥ïŒå®¶æïŒïŒå·»ïŒå·ïŒïŒé ïŒïŒæé«è£äžå°æ±ºå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒæ¥ïŒæ°éïŒïŒå·»ïŒå·ïŒïŒïŒïŒé ïŒïŒãçµãŠïŒå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒæ¥ã«æ°æ³ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ãæ¹æ£ããïŒé芪暩è ïŒé身äžç£è·èŠªïŒã«ãåã®ç£è·ã®äžå 容ãšããŠç£è·ã®æš©å©ãæ ¹æ ãæããããšã«ãªã£ãã
暪æµå®¶å¯©å¹³æ8幎4æ30æ¥ïŒå®¶æ49å·»3å·75é ïŒãåã®çŠç¥ãšããèŠå°ããã¯,ç¶æ¯ã®ãã¡ç£è·æè²ãæ åœããªã芪ïŒä»¥äžãé芪暩è 芪ããšãããïŒãïŒå¯èœãªéã芪暩è 芪ã«ããæªæçåã®ç£è·æè²ã«ååããããšãéèŠã§ããïŒãã®ããïŒé芪暩è 芪ãšæªæçåãæ¥è§Šã»äº€æµã®æ©äŒãæã€ããšãæãŸããããšãã,æ°æ³äžææã®èŠå®ã¯ãªãããã©ãïŒåã®ç£è·ã«é¢ããåŠåã®äžç°ãšããŠé¢å©åŸã®é芪暩è 芪ã«ããæªæçåãšã®é¢äŒäº€æµãè¯å®ãããŠãããã
ãã®ããã«é芪暩è ïŒé身äžç£è·è ïŒã«ã€ããŠåã«å¯Ÿããç£è·ã®è¡äœ¿ãèªããããŠãããã€ãŸãé¢å©åŸã®èŠªãåãç£è·ããæš©å©è ã§ããããšã¯åŠå®ãããªããããã§åã©ãã®å©çïŒæš©å©ïŒã¯åã©ãèªèº«ã確ä¿ãããã®ã§ãããïŒèŠªæš©ã«å æ¬ããããã®ãåŠãåã«æããæš©å©ã«ãã£ãŠåããããã®ãšè§£ãããããšããïŒç£è·ã®æš©å©è ãïŒåã®è«æ±æš©ã«ã€ãïŒã©ã®ãããªä»£çæš©ãè¡äœ¿ãã¹ããæ€èšãã¹ãã§ããã
å¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥æé«è£ç¬¬äžå°æ³å»·å€æ±ºïŒå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒåïŒç¬¬ïŒïŒïŒïŒå·ïŒ
ãåãç£è·ããç¶æ¯ã®äžæ¹ã«ããåœå¢ãè¶ããŠæ¥æ¬ãžã®é£ãå»ãããããåãïŒåœè©²é£ãå»ãããã芪ã®äžã«ãšã©ãŸããåŠãã«ã€ããŠã®ææ決å®ãããå ŽåïŒåœè©²ææ決å®ã¯ïŒèªèº«ãå°æ¥ãããã®åœãæ¬æ ãšããŠç掻ããŠããã®ããšããåé¡ãšé¢ããã
å±±å£åå€äºã¯ïŒãã®ããã«åºæ¬çå¹³çãç §ãããŠåããæ瀺ãããã€ãŸãåã¯ïŒé£ãå»ãããã芪ã®äžã«ãšã©ãŸããåŠãã«ã€ããŠã®ææ決å®ãããå ŽåïŒèªèº«ãå°æ¥ãããã®å°åãæ¬æ ãšããŠç掻ããŠããã®ããšããåé¡ãçããã®ãšåæ§ã«ïŒèªèº«ãå°æ¥ãããã®èœåãäž»äœãšããŠç掻ããŠããã®ããšããåé¡ãçãããåã¯èœåãè²ãã«ãããäž¡æ§ããå¹³çã«ç¿åŸãããäžæ¹ãæ¬ ããã°ïŒåã¯éžæã®äœå°ãªãåãããããã人ã«ãã£ãŠèãæ¹ãéãã®ã§ããããïŒå€«å©Šã®èãæ¹ãéããšããçç±ã§ïŒèªåã®èãã§è²ãŠãããšããææã®åŒ·ãããç£è·æš©ã«åºå·ããŠïŒçžæ芪ããéé¢ããããã«ç§åã§é£ãå»ããšããããšå€ããããïŒããã¯æ¯é ã®åŽé¢ã匷ãç §ãããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒåã«äŸåãçãããšãããã®ã§ããã
æ¬æ¥ïŒåãèªåã®ææ³ïŒè¯å¿ïŒå®æïŒé埳ïŒå²åŠïŒè¶£å³ãªã©æ§ã ãªèœåãæ§ç¯ããããšã¯ïŒèšèã®èªã¿æžããå°é£ãªå¹Œå°æããåã¯ïŒç¶ãšæ¯ãšïŒãã®äž¡æ¹ããç¿åŸãããã¹ããŒããé³æ¥œãªã©ã«éããïŒèœåãšã¯å¹Œå°ã®ãªãã¹ãæ©ãææããææ§ãè²ãããšã«ãã£ãŠïŒæ人ãšãªãååŸã®ææã«å€§ããªææãã¿ããããã®ã§ãããéå£ç掻ã«ãããŠç€ŸäŒçã«ç¿åŸããŠãããã®ã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒåŠæ ¡ãªã©ã«åå ããŠããã§ããããåç¬èŠªæš©åã§åãã«å®å®ããç掻åºç€ãããæ§ã«ã¿ããŠãïŒåã«ã¯äžå¹³çãçããŠããç°å¢äžã§ããäºã¯åŠããïŒç§åã®è¡äœ¿ã§èŠªãåãé£ãå»ãå ŽåïŒå€«å©Šã¯å ±å芪暩äžã§ããããšãå€ãïŒäžæ¹ã®èŠªæš©ã劚害ãããŠããïŒæãã¯åãèªç±ã«äººæ Œã圢æããããã®é©æ£ãªç£è·ãæ±ããæš©å©ãé芪暩è ïŒé身äžç£è·è ïŒã«å¯ŸããŠåã®å¥å šãªçºéãæ±ãæè²ïŒæè²ãæ±ããæš©å©ã劚害ãããŠãããšãããã®ã§ããã
ã€ãŸã芪ãšåã®èº«åäžã§åœ¢æããææ³ãè¯å¿ïŒå®æ芳ãªã©ã¯ïŒç¶åé¢ä¿ã§ç¿åŸãããã®ãããã°ïŒæ¯åé¢ä¿ã§ç¿åŸãããã®ããã£ãŠïŒããã¯åã«ãšã£ãŠç¶åé¢ä¿ãšæ¯åé¢ä¿ããåå¥ã«æè²ãåããæš©å©ã§ããå¶éããããã®ã§ã¯ãªããåã¯ïŒãã®äžå¹³çãç¥ãããšãïŒåããèªç¶ã«ä¿®æ£ããããšäžèªç±ãã解æŸãæ±ãããïŒããã¯åãšèŠªã®èªç¶ã®æš©å©ã§ããïŒåããç¡ããèªç¶æ²»çèœåæãã¯åç©çæ¬èœã§ããã身äžç£è·è ã®æè²ã«éåãèŠããæïŒææžãæ±ããããšã¯èªç¶ã®ããšã§ããããïŒé身äžç£è·è ãç£ç£ä¿è·è ãšããŠïŒãã®åœ¹å²ãåããæ±ãããããã®ã§ããã芪ããåããæè²ãæè²ãåçç¿åŸã¯å šãŠäžæè²ã§ãã£ãŠïŒåãã®èœåã«å¿ããŠç¶åé¢ä¿ãšæ¯åé¢ä¿ãšåå¥ã«åããæè²ã¯ïŒãã©ã€ãã·ãŒãšããŠåºæ¬çå¹³çã§ãªããã°ãªããïŒåã®ïŒå©çïŒæš©å©ãæåªå ã«ä¿éããªããã°ãªããªãã
é¢æ¥äº€æžãšåŒ·å¶å·è¡/éå ä¿®è£å€å®åã³æ²Œç°å¹žéè£å€å®(å€äŸã¿ã€ã 㺠1087å·42é )
ãé¢æ¥äº€æžã®å¯©å€ã«ãã£ãŠåµåè ãè² ãã¹ã矩åã¯ïŒåã«åµæš©è ãšæªæ幎è ãšãé¢æ¥ãããã°è¶³ãããšãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã»ã»æªæ幎è ãå æ¬çãªèº«äžç£è·ã®çŸ©åè ãšããŠååã«ã±ã¢ãã»ã»ç©æ¥µçã«éç£è·èŠªãšã®äº€æµã確ä¿ããã¹ã矩åãªã®ã§ãã£ãŠã»ã»ã
ãã®ããã«èŠªæš©ãšã¯åã©ãã®å©çïŒæš©å©ïŒãä¿è·ãã¹ãæš©å©ãšçŸ©åã«åºã¥ãïŒæ°æ³ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ã¯ãã¬ã³ããªãŒãã¢ã¬ã³ãã«ãŒã«ïŒå¯å®¹æ§ã®ååïŒã«åºã¥ããã®ãšããŠèŠå®ããªãããŠãããšè§£ãããããšã¯åŠå®ãããªãã
ã€ãŸã芪ãšåã®èªç¶æš©ãç §ããã°ïŒåœå æ³ã«ãããŠé¢å©åŸïŒèŠªæš©ãç²åŸãããæš©å©è ã¯åç¬ã§ããããïŒèªç¶ã«æãã芪ååçµ±åïŒèŠªåæ§ç¯å®çŸïŒã«ã€ãé芪暩è ãšåãšã®èªç¶ã«æããåµåïŒè²¬åïŒãåç¬ã«æãã決å®ããªããããšããããããã§é芪暩è ã¯åã®é€è²ã«é¢ããåµåïŒè²¬åïŒãšããŠé€è²è²»ãé¢äŒäº€æµãªã©åµåãšããŠçµŠä»ã®ç¹å®ããªãããªããšããŠãïŒå¥éïŒèª¿åãªã©ã«ãã£ãŠåã決ããªããã°ãªããªãå¶åºŠãšãªã£ãŠãããã€ãŸãåè°é¢å©ãªã©ã«ããå¥éåã決ããè¡ããªã䞡芪ã®å ŽåïŒäžæ¹ã«éå®ããŠåç¬ã«èŠªæš©è ã決å®ããæç¹ã§é芪暩è ã¯å ±å芪暩äžã«æããåµåïŒè²¬åïŒãå 責ããïŒæåŠããŸããéããšãããã®ã§ããã
ãã§ã¯å¥éïŒãããã®åã決ãã«ãããŠïŒäºããå¢å ããŠãããïŒåã®å©çã«è³ããé¢å©å¶åºŠãèå¯ããã°ïŒããããé¢å©å±ã«åé¡ããããé¢å©å±ã«é¢äŒäº€æµãšé€è²è²»ã®ãã§ãã¯æ¬ããããïŒåãæãã芪ã®åçåºæºãšåã®æããªã芪ã®åçåºæºãåãã§ãããåã«å¯ŸããŠãäººæ Œæš©ãèªããã¹ãã§ããããïŒåçåºæºãåãã§ãã£ãŠã¯ãªããªãã
åœå æ³ã§ã¯ç£è·æš©ãšèŠªæš©ã¯åãïŒèª¿åå眮䞻矩ã«åºã¥ãïŒå ±å芪暩äžã«å¥å± ããéïŒç£è·è ãå ã«æ±ºå®ããããšãäžè¬çã§ãããåã®ç£è·è ãæå®ããå Žåã®ç£è·æš©ã¯ïŒåºæ¬çã«ã¯èº«äžç£è·æš©ã«éããããããã§å¥å± 芪ã¯é¢äŒäº€æµãšããé€è²ïŒæè²ã«é¢ããåãšèŠªã®èªç¶æš©ä¿éãäºãããšã«ãªããããã¯å¥å± 芪ã®é¢æ¥äº€æžæš©ããç£è·ã®äžå 容ã«é¢ããæš©å©ãšããŠèªããããŠãããïŒãã®æ ¹æ ã¯åã®ç£è·ïŒåŠšå®³æé€ïŒé©æ£æªçœ®ïŒè«æ±æš©ã®ä»£çæš©è ãšããŠäºãããšãšåèŽããã
身äžç£è·è ã¯é€è²ã«é¢ããåã®è²¡ç£ç®¡çã®ä»£çæš©ãäºãããšã«ãªããåè¿°ããé¢å©å±åçã®æç¹ã§å ±åé€è²èšç»æžãªã©ã®æåºçŸ©åãªã©å¶åºŠåããã°ïŒãã®åé¡ã¯è£å€æã®è² æ ã倧ããæžå°ãããå¹æã«æåŸ ãæãŠããé¢å©å±ã§è¡æ¿ãé¢äžãïŒè§£æ±ºã®äžæ¹æ³ãå¶åºŠåããŠããã°äºãã¯æžããåã«ãšã£ãŠäž¡èŠªãäºãäºããæããšããã§ã¯ãªãã
ãæŽã«ä»ãå ãããšïŒç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒã§åã®å± ææå®ãããææè ã«å¯Ÿãè£å€æãç£è·è ãšããŠèªããããã§ãããç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒã§åã®å± ææå®ãããããšã¯çžæ芪ã®èŠªæš©è¡äœ¿ã劚害ããŠããïŒåœç¶åŠšå®³æé€è«æ±ãããäžæ¹èŠªã®èŠªæš©æ¿«çšãææããããïŒåã«åœ±é¿ãåã¶ããšãæžå¿µãã¹ã芳ç¹ããè£å€æãææã®ç¶ç¶æ§ãç¶ç¶æ§ã®ååã«åºã¥ã劥åœãšè©äŸ¡ããã±ãŒã¹ãåŸã絶ããªãã
ãšããã§ä¿è·åœä»€ãšã¯ïŒåœä»€ãåãããã®ãïŒå¯Ÿè±¡è ã«å¯ŸããŠè¿å¯ã£ãŠã¯ãããªãåœä»€ã§ãã£ãŠïŒå¯Ÿè±¡è ãåã®å± æãå€æŽããªããã°ãªããªãåœä»€ã§ã¯ãªããé¢å©åã«äžæ¹èŠªãçžæ芪ã«åæãªãåãé£ãå»ãç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒã¯ïŒé¢å©åŸã®èŠªæš©ã«ã€ã奪ãåããšãã«åªäœã«ããããã®åæ©ãšãªã£ãŠãããåŸã£ãŠïŒçåœã«é¢ããèšåãæ€èšŒãããçæ£ïŒ€ïŒ¶ãããã°åã«ã€ããŠã¯å ç«¥çžè«æã®ã·ã§ã«ã¿ãŒã«ææžãæ±ããã¹ãã§ããã芪暩åæ¢ãåªå€±ãè£å€æã«æ±ããæš©éã¯å ç«¥çžè«æã®é·ãæãããåã¯å ç«¥çžè«æãå ¬çã«ææžãïŒåã©ãã®æç¶ã代ç人å¶åºŠã掻çšãïŒå®¶åºè£å€æã«ç£è·è ã芪暩è ã®æ±ºå®ãæ±ããããšã¯ç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒçŠæ¢ã®ååã«æ²¿ã£ã察å¿ã®äžæ¹æ³ãšãããã
ç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒã§åã®å± æãæå®ããã°ä¿è·çãªåæ³çãªãé£ãåºããã§ã¯ãªãéæ³æ§ã®é«ãæ¯é çãªãé£ãå»ãããšãªãïŒåã«å¯Ÿãããææãã®ç¶æ ãç¶ç¶ãããäžè¬çã«ã¯ïŒãã®ææè ã®æ¯é åããã匷ãŸãïŒåãææããéæŸããªãäºã§å€«å©Šãããé«èè€åããïŒæãã¯çŽäºãæ¿åããäºäŸãå€ãããããåã¯èªèº«ã§ç掻ãæŽçã§ããïŒææè ã®æ¯é ããèªåã§è±åºã§ããé¢å¥ã匷å¶ããïŒèªç±æš©ãå¶éããéæŸãããªãããšã§äŸåãçããã
ããã§æ¬æ¥ïŒæ¥æ¬åœæ²æ³ç¬¬ïŒïŒæ¡ïŒé ã«ããã芪åã®èº«åä¿éãåïŒïŒæ¡ïŒé ïŒæ³ã®äžã®å¹³çãä¿éããæ¡é ãç §ããã°ïŒåã¯ç€ŸäŒç身åãéãã©ïŒãã¹ãŠã®åœæ°ã¯ïŒåã©ããå«ããŠæ³ã®äžã«å¹³çãšããŠïŒåã«ã€ããŠãç¬ç«ããæš©å©ãä¿éãããã¹ããšè§£ããããåŸã£ãŠïŒå®èŠªã§ãã£ãŠãç§åã§åãææããããšã¯çžæ芪ã«å¯ŸããŠèŠªæš©è¡äœ¿ãæ±ããåã®è«æ±æš©ãå®è³ªåŠšå®³ããããšãããã®ã§ããã
ãã€ïŒå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒæ¥æé«è£å€§æ³å»·æ±ºå®ïŒè£å€é·ã»ç«¹åŽåå é·å®ïŒã§éå«¡åºåãæããæš©å©ã¯å«¡åºåãšåçã«ä¿éããŠïŒçžç¶ãå¹³çã«æ±ããæš©å©ãèªããŠããïŒåã©ãã¯å¹Žéœ¢ã«åãããŠããªãã
ãŸãæ±äº¬å®¶å¯©æåïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒïŒæïŒïŒæ¥ïŒå®¶æïŒïŒå·»ïŒå·ïŒïŒé ïŒ
ããã®æš©å©ã¯æªæçåã®çŠç¥ã害ããããšããªãéãïŒå¶éããåã¯å¥ªãããããšã¯ãªãã
倧éªå®¶å¯©å¹³æ5幎12æ22æ¥ïŒå®¶æ47å·»4å·45é ïŒ
ãåã©ãã¯ãäººæ Œã®å®æããããïŒå¿èº«ã®å¥å šãªçºéãæ±ããåºæ¬ç人暩ãä¿éãããã°ãªããªã(æ²æ³ç¬¬ïŒïŒæ¡ç¬¬ïŒé ïŒ æè²åºæ¬æ³ç¬¬ïŒæ¡)ã
ïŒäžç¥ïŒäººæ Œã®åæºãªçºéã«äžå¯æ¬ ãªäž¡èŠªã®æè²ã®äº«åãæ±ããåã®æš©å©ãšããŠã®æ§è³ªããæããã
æåïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥æé«è£å€æ±º(æåïŒïŒïŒãªïŒïŒïŒïŒ)
ãå°ãªããšã芪ãæ æåã¯é倱ã«ãã€ãŠå³çŸ©åãææ ãïŒãã®çµæïŒåãäžå©çã被ã€ããšããã°ïŒèŠªã¯ïŒåã«å¯ŸããŠäžæ³è¡çºäžã®æå®³è³ å矩åãè² ãã
ïŒäžç¥ïŒãæªæ幎ã®åã䞡芪ãšãšãã«å ±åç掻ããããããšã«ãã€ãŠäº«åããããšã®ã§ããç¶èŠªããã®ææ ïŒç¶åã®å ±åç掻ãçã¿åºããšããã®å®¶åºçç掻å©ççã¯ïŒæªæ幎ã®åã®äººæ Œåœ¢æã«åŒ·ã圱é¿ãäžããã«ã¯ããããªããã®ã§ããïŒãã€ïŒäººéæ§ã®æ¬è³ªã«æ·±ãããããåããã®ã§ããããšãèãããšïŒæ³åŸã¯ïŒããããžã®äŸµå®³ã«å¯ŸããŠã¯åãä¿è·ã®æãå·®ã延ã¹ãªããã°ãªããªãã
æ±äº¬å®¶è£å «çåæ¯å¯©å¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥ïŒå®¶æïŒïŒå·»ïŒïŒå·ïŒïŒé ïŒ
ã家äºäºä»¶æç¶æ³ã®å¶å®åŸïŒåã©ãã¯èŠªãä»ããã«é¢äŒäº€æµãç³ãç«ãŠãäœå°ãããã®ã§ïŒãã®ãããªäºä»¶ãçããããšãèãããããã
ã€ãŸãåãèªç±ææã«ããåžæãèªå·±æ±ºå®ããã«ãããïŒå©å®³é¢ä¿äººã§ããåãåå ãã¹ããšãïŒåã®çŠç¥ãåºæ¬ç念ã«ããïŒç¬¬äžçŸ©çã«ã¯èªäž»è§£æ±ºãä¿ãããã«ïŒåã®æç¶è«æ±ïŒé©æ£æªçœ®è«æ±ïŒåŠšå®³æé€è«æ±ïŒæš©ãä¿éãã¹ããšãããã®ã§ããã
åãå©å®³é¢ä¿äººãšããŠïŒãã®æš©å©æ§ãè¯å®ããå€äŸãšããŠã¯ïŒæ±äº¬é«æ±ºæåïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥ïŒå®¶æïŒïŒå·»ïŒå·ïŒïŒé ïŒïŒå€§éªå®¶å¯©æåïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥ïŒå®¶æïŒïŒå·»ïŒïŒå·ïŒïŒé ïŒïŒæ±äº¬å®¶å¯©æåïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥ïŒå®¶æïŒïŒå·»ïŒå·ïŒïŒé ïŒïŒå€§å家äžæŽ¥æ¯éšå¯©æåïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥ïŒå®¶æïŒïŒå·»ïŒå·ïŒïŒïŒé ïŒïŒæµŠå家審æåïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒæ¥ïŒå®¶æïŒïŒå·»ïŒå·ïŒïŒïŒé ïŒïŒæ±äº¬å®¶å¯©æåïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥ïŒå®¶æïŒïŒå·»ïŒå·ïŒïŒé ïŒïŒåè家審平æïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥ïŒå®¶æïŒïŒå·»ïŒå·ïŒïŒé ïŒïŒå²¡å±±å®¶å¯©å¹³æïŒå¹ŽïŒïŒæïŒæ¥ïŒå®¶æïŒïŒå·»ïŒïŒå·ïŒïŒé ïŒïŒå€§éªå®¶å¯©å¹³æïŒå¹ŽïŒïŒæïŒïŒæ¥ïŒå®¶æïŒïŒå·»ïŒå·ïŒïŒé ïŒïŒçŠå²¡é«æ±ºå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒïŒæïŒïŒæ¥ïŒæ°éïŒïŒå·»ïŒå·ïŒïŒïŒïŒé ïŒïŒãªã©äžéšã§ããçŸåšããªãå¢ãç¶ããŠããã
ãããã瀺ãåã®æš©å©æ§ã«ã€ã劚害ãå®åéçšãšããŠãŸããéã£ãŠããããèåŸ é²æ¢ã®èŠ³ç¹ã«ãã£ãŠå ±å芪暩ã«ããªããã°ãªããªãåçççç±ããããšãããã®ã§ãããç£è·æš©è ã«å¯ŸãïŒæ¬¡çã«ä»£çæš©ãæããããææåããã°è§£æ±ºã暡玢ã§ãããïŒçŸè¡æ³ã§ã¯ïŒèŠªæš©ã奪åããã芪ã代çããŠè¡ããªãè«æ±ãã»ãšãã©ã§ããã
èåŸ ããã芪暩è ã®äžã«å ç«¥çžè«æããæ»ããïŒèŠªæš©è ãšã®ç掻ã«èŠæ ®ããŠèªæ®ºããå°å¥³ã®äºä»¶ã§ã¯ïŒå ç«¥çžè«æã¯èŠªæš©è ã«å¯ŸããŠèŠªæš©ãåæ¢ãåªå€±ãããïŒèŠªæš©ãæããªãå®èŠªãåãææžãããšããã³ã¹ç¢ºä¿ã®çºã«å ç«¥çžè«æãžé瀺è«æ±ãããã®ã®ïŒèŠªæš©è ã§ãªããšããçç±ã§æåŠããç¶ãïŒå°å¥³ã¯èªæ®ºããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒãã®é瀺ã®è«æ±æš©ãããã£ãŠå±±å£çãçžæåã蚎èšã«è³ã£ãã
çµæãšããŠè£å€æãã芪å¯ãªçŽç³»è¡æãé瀺ãè«æ±ããæš©å©ãèªãã決å®ãåºãããããå®åã§ã¯ã»ãšãã©ãé»å¡ãã§é瀺ãããã®ã§ãããã€ãŸãåãšå¥å± 芪ãšã®ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒïŒèªå·±æ±ºå®ïŒæš©ãšåãšåå± èŠªãšã®ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒïŒèªå·±æ±ºå®ïŒæš©ãåå¥ã«ä¿éãããŠãããïŒæªã å®åãšããŠéçšã«åæ ãããŠããªãã
åã®å©çã®ããã®é¢äŒäº€æµïŒæ³åŸæå瀟)ïŒïŒïŒé 以äž
ãã©ã³ã¹æ°æ³å žïŒïŒïŒæ¡
芪暩è¡äœ¿ãããªã芪ã¯ïŒåã®é€è²åã³è²æãç£ç£ããæš©å©ãä¿æããã
ãã©ã³ã¹æ°æ³å žïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒæ¡
ïŒç¶æ¯ã®ïŒèšªåæš©ããã³å®¿æ³ãããæš©å©ã¯ïŒé倧ãªäºç±ã«ããã®ã§ãªããã°ïŒä»æ¹ã®èŠªã«å¯ŸããŠæåŠã§ããªãã
ãã©ã³ã¹ã®å ±å芪暩å¶åºŠã®ããšã§ã¯ïŒç¶æ¯ã®èšªåæš©ã®èŠå®ã¯ïŒäŸå€çã«åç¬èŠªæš©ãšãªã£ãæã®ã¿ã«é©çšãããããããŠïŒåç¬èŠªæš©è ãšãªããªãã£ã芪ã蚪åæš©ãè¡äœ¿ããå Žåã«ã¯ïŒãé倧ãªäºç±ãããªããã°ïŒãã®èŠªã®èšªåæš©ã¯åŠå®ãããªãã
ãã®èšªåæš©ã¯åã®å¥å šãªçºéãé€è²åã³è²æãç£ç£ããæš©å©ãšããŠãèªããŠããã
ããããç §ããã°ïŒæªæ幎åã®æç¶ãã®æ¬è³ªãšããŠé芪暩è ã«ç£è·ã®æš©å©ãèªãïŒããã代çæš©ã¯æ£æçã«å¶éãããªã©å€±åœã§ãããïŒçŸè¡æ³ã«ããå®åã¯é芪暩è ã«è«æ±ä»£çæš©ãèªããªãéçšã§ãããåŸãïŒããããæªæ幎åã®èªç±ææã«ã€ããŠé芪暩è ã確èªã§ããªããããšããçç±ã§ïŒåèªèº«ã«è¡çºèœåãç¡ããšå€æãïŒä»£çã®æš©éè¡äœ¿ãèªããªãå€æããªãããã®ã§ããã°äžåœãšèšããããããªãã
ã€ãŸãæåãäžæãäŒããããšãåºæ¥ãïŒæžé¢ã®èªã¿æžããå°é£ã§ããåã®å ŽåïŒäŸãã°ç²Ÿç¥çã身äœçé害ãæã€å ç«¥ãæªæ幎åãæ³å®ä»£ç人ã«ãããã«èªãæç¶è¡çºã§ããå Žåã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒèŠªæš©è ã»åŸèŠäººã代çããŠæç¶è¡çºããããšãã§ãããšããŠããïŒå®¶äºæç¶æ³ïŒïŒæ¡ïŒã
ãã®ããšããå©å€åãšèªç¥èŠªãšã®é¢ä¿ãå«ãããšïŒåã®è«æ±æš©ã®ä»£çæš©ã芪暩è ã«ã®ã¿ã«éå®ããåœå æ³ã¯åã®çŠç¥ã«ãšã£ãŠåŠ¥åœãšã¯ãããªããã¹ãŠã§ãŒãã³ã¯äºå®å©ãïŒïŒïŒ ãè¶ ããå¢ãã§ãããæ¥æ¬ã§ãäºå®å©ã¯å¢å åŸåã«ããïŒäºå®å©ã®é¢ä¿æ§ãç §ããã°ïŒåã«ãšã£ãŠèŠªãé¢å©ããŠããŠãäºå®å©ãšäœãå€ããã¯ç¡ããã€ãŸãçŸå¶åºŠã§ãã£ãŠãïŒå ±å芪責任ïŒæãã¯å ±åç£è·æš©ã®èŠ³ç¹ããæªæ幎è ã®é©æ£ç£è·åŠšå®³ã®æé€è«æ±ã«ã€ãé芪暩è ã«ä»£çæš©ãèªããªããã°ãªããïŒãŸãé芪暩è ã®çŽç³»è¡æã«ïŒãã®æš©å©ãçžç¶ããããã®ã§ãã£ãŠãç¹æ®µã®çç±ããªãéãåŠå®ã¯ãããªãã
ããã§ç¹å¥ä»£ç人ã®éžä»»ïŒå®¶äºïŒïŒæ¡ïŒæ°æ³ç¬¬ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ïŒããããïŒãŸãèåŸ ãææããããšããã³ã¹ãå ç«¥çžè«æã«å¯ŸããŠèŠªæš©ã奪åããã芪ã代çããŠé瀺ã®è«æ±ãè¡ããªãã®ã§ãããªãïŒä¿è·ããå ç«¥çžè«æãé·ã®æš©éã§åã©ãã®æç¶ã代ç人ãèšçœ®ãã¹ãå¶åºŠåãå¿ èŠãªã®ã§ããã
ç¹ã«éå«¡åºåãæªæçæã®åã©ããªã©ã«å¯ŸããŠææ確èªã®çŸ©åãæèšããŠãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãïŒæš©å©ã«åºã¥ãè¡çºèœåã¯ïŒçŸè¡æ³ã§ã¯èŠªæš©è ãããã代çã§ãããå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒæ¥æé«è£å€§æ³å»·æ±ºå®ïŒè£å€é·ã»ç«¹åŽåå é·å®ïŒãç §ããã°ïŒéå«¡åºåã®è«æ±æš©ã«ã€ã代çããæš©å©ã¯ïŒäž¡èŠªã®ã©ã¡ãããæåŠããŠãæåŠèªäœããŸããéããªãããã«ã¯ïŒäž¡èŠªå ±ã«æããã¹ããã®ãšã解ããã
æ®æŽïŒåã®ææææ¡èŠå®ïŒïŒïŒïŒæ¡ïŒé æºçšå®¶äºïŒïŒæ¡ïŒã¯åã®ææãææ¡ããããã«ãåªãããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒåã®ææ確èªã«ãããŠæç¶ä»¥åã®ç¢ºèªçŸ©åã¯ææåãããŠãããïŒåªããŠã¿ãŠåã®ææ確èªãåºæ¥ããšãïŒæš©å©ãå¶éãããããšã¯ãªãïŒåœç¶ïŒåŠå®ãããªãã®ã§ããã
æ°äºèšŽèšæ³äžïŒèº«åé¢ä¿ãåé¡ãšãªã家äºäºä»¶æç¶ã®æ§è³ªäžïŒã§ããéãæ¬äººã®ææå°éãæ±ããããããšããïŒå®¶äºäºä»¶æç¶æ³ã§ã¯ïŒæ³å®ä»£ç人ã«ãããã«èªãæå¹ã«æç¶è¡çºãããããšãã§ãããã®ãšããŠïŒåã®ç£è·ã«é¢ããå Žåã¯å®¶äºïŒïŒïŒæ¡æºçšèŠå®ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ïŒå·ïŒïŒïŒïŒæ¡ïŒé ïŒïŒé ã§èŠå®ãããããšã¯ïŒæèšãããŠããã
ããããªãã身åé¢ä¿ãåé¡ãšãªã家äºäºä»¶åã³å®¶äºèª¿åã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒåœäºè æ¬äººã®äººæ Œã«åœ±é¿ããäºãç §ããïŒãã§ããã ãæ¬äººã®ææã«åºã¥ãããšãæãŸãããããšèããããŠããŠïŒäººæ Œæš©ãåŠå®ããŠããªããäººæ Œæš©ãåºæ¬çã«å°éããããã®ã§ããïŒäºåã«æ¬äººã®ææ確èªïŒè¡çºèœåã®ç¢ºèªã矩åä»ããèšèŒã§ã¯ç¡ãïŒãããã®ç¢ºèªãæç¶ãåŸã§ãã£ãŠãåŠå®ãããªããã€ãŸãæç¶ããæ¬äººã®ææã«åºã¥ããã®ãæãŸãããšãããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒæç¶ããæ¬äººã®ææã«åºã¥ããªããšãïŒãã®äººæ Œæš©ã¯å°éããïŒèŠªïŒèŠªå¯ãªçŽç³»è¡æïŒãæªæ幎åã®è«æ±æš©ã®ä»£çæš©ãæããããšã¯åŠå®ãããªãã
ãŸãïŒãããã¯åã®æš©å©å®çŸïŒäººæ Œæš©ã®å°éãç®çã§ããããšããïŒèŠªæš©è ã®ä»£çæš©ãšããŠã¿ãã°ïŒäžæ¹ã®ã¿ã§ä»£çæš©è¡äœ¿ããã£ããšããŠãïŒãããæããã«ä»æ¹ã®èŠªæš©ã䟵害ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãïŒäž¡èŠªã®åæãå¿ ããã矩åãšããŠæèšãããŠããªãããšãã家äºäºä»¶æç¶æ³ç¬¬ïŒïŒæ¡ã«åºã¥ãïŒä»æ¹èŠªæš©è ã®åæãªããšãè«æ±åºæ¥ããã®ãšè§£ãããã
ã€ãŸãïŒæªæ幎åã®å¥å šãªçºéãªã©é©åãªç£è·ïŒé©æ£æªçœ®ïŒè«æ±ã«åŠšå®³ãçããéã®åŠšå®³æé€è«æ±æš©ã«ã€ãïŒèŠªæš©è ã§ã¯ãªã芪ïŒèŠªå¯ãªçŽç³»è¡æïŒã«ä»£çæš©ãèªããã¹ãã§ãããåã®çŠç¥ã«é©ããïŒåã®å©çã«è³ããéçšãšããŠïŒæªæ幎åã®æš©å©ä¿éã®èŠ³ç¹ããä»åŸæ€èšãã¹ãéèŠãªèª²é¡ãšããããã
ïŒïŒã®äžèšã«èšããïŒåã¯é¢å¥åé¢ã«ãã£ãŠéåžžã«å€§ããªç²Ÿç¥çã¹ãã¬ã¹ãçãããã®ãšããŠïŒãã§ã«ãšããã³ã¹ã¯èç©ãããŠããŠãããé·æéã®èŠªååé¢ïŒæãã¯èŠªåç Žå£ã«ãã粟ç¥çãã¡ãŒãžãšïŒææã«ããäŸåãªã©ã®åœ±é¿ã¯åãåé¿ãããã¹ãïŒæªæ幎åã®é©æ£æªçœ®ãè«æ±ããæš©å©ãè©äŸ¡ããããã¹ãã§ããã
ãŠïŒé¢å©åŸã®å ±å芪暩ã¯æ°æ³ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ã«ãã£ãŠçŠæ¢ãããŠãããå¹³æïŒïŒå¹Žã«èŠçŽããè¡ããå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒæ¥ã«æœè¡ãããã芪暩åªå€±å¶åºŠã移è¡ïŒäžåçã«èŠªæš©ãåªå€±ãããæ°æ³ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ãæŸçœ®ããç¶ããŠããããšã¯åœäŒè°å¡ã®æ æ ¢ãšããããç¶æ ã§ããããã 芪暩ã奪ãåãããã«ãããçŽäºã«ã€ãïŒåé¡èŠãããŠããã®ã¯äžèšã®éãç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒã§ããããªããªãé¢å©åŸã®å ±åç£è·ãçŠæ¢ããæ³ã¯ãªããïŒå®åäžïŒå ±åç£è·ãçŠæ¢ããŠããæŽå²ãããããã§ããã
å¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥æé«è£å€æ第äžå°æ³å»·å€æ±ºã§å±±å£åæé«è£å€äºãå ¬èšãããé£ãå»ãããšãã£ãè©äŸ¡ã¯åŠ¥åœã§ããã決ããŠåæ³çã«é£ãåºãããã®ã§ã¯ãªããããŒã°æ¡çŽã«æ¹åããããšã§ç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒçŠæ¢ã®ååã¯æ確åãããŠãããããã¯åœå æ³ã§ç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒãçŠæ¢ãããŠããªããã°äžäœçºãçããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒããããããŒã°æ¡çŽã«æ¹åã§ããªãã
æé«è£å€æåïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒïŒæïŒæ¥ïŒæ°éïŒïŒå·»ïŒå·ïŒïŒïŒïŒé ïŒãç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒã¯ååãšããŠæ³ã®çŠæ¢ãããšããã§ããããšããïŒããŒã°æ¡çŽã«ã€ããåœãè·šãããšããæ§è³ªããç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒãçŠæ¢ã®ååããåªäœã«è©äŸ¡ããã±ãŒã¹ããã£ããšããŠãïŒæ¬æ¥ïŒåœãè·šããªãç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒãåæ³ãšããã°ïŒåœå®¶éã®å·®å¥ãçããããšãåŠå®ãããïŒåœå æ³ã®ååã¯æ¹å»ãããæ¥æ¬ããå€åœã«ããŒã°æ¡çŽã«åºã¥ããŠåã®åŒãæž¡ããè«æ±ããæç¶ãã¯ïŒæ¥æ¬ã®åœå æ³ã«ãããŠç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒãçžæ芪ã®ç£è·æš©äŸµå®³ãšè©äŸ¡ãããã
æ®æŽïŒå©å§»äžã®å ŽåïŒæ¥æ¬ã®åœå æ³ã«ãããŠïŒå ±å芪暩äžã§ããããåãé£ãå»ãç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒãçžæ芪ã®èŠªæš©è¡äœ¿åŠšå®³ã§ããããšã¯åŠå®ãããªããããããåœéæ³èŠãèª å®ã«éµå®ããããšãå®ããå第ïŒïŒæ¡ïŒé ã®æ矩ã§ãã趣æšã§ãããã
ããã§æ¬æ¥ïŒåæ³ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ã¯è»œåŸ®ãªç¯çœªçãšããŠç³å眪ã®å¯Ÿè±¡ã§ãããïŒç¹æ®µã®çç±ãªãäžåœã«èŠªåãé¢å¥åŒ·å¶ããã粟ç¥çè² æ ãéã¿ãã°ïŒåã«ãšã£ãŠæ±ºããŠè»œåŸ®ãªãã®ãšã¯ãããªããç§åã®è¡äœ¿ã§ææè ã®å®è³ªæåŠã«ãã芪åã®åé¢åŒ·èŠããŸããéããªãããã«ïŒå®åã®æåã«ã€ããŠãæ確ã«çŠæ¢ãã¹ãæ³æŽåãå¿ èŠã§ããã
ãšïŒæ³åçã¯ïŒã³ãããŽã£ã«ã¹ã®åœ±é¿ã§é¢äŒäº€æµãæãç£è·è ãå¢å ããããšãåãïŒãã¬ãé»è©±ã®å©çšãåŒã³æããŠãããããã¯åã«å¯Ÿãã身äžç£è·è ã«ããæ¯é ã®åŒ·ããæžå¿µããŠããã芪暩è ã決å®ããã°ææè ãšããäœçœ®ã¥ããšã¯ãªããªããåŸã£ãŠïŒãã€ãã®åç¬èŠªæš©éæ²èšŽèšã§ç §ããããæ¯é ã®åŽé¢ã®è©äŸ¡ãšåèŽããŠããããšã¯åŠããªãã
ãšããã§æ§ã ã«èªç²ãèŠè«ããïŒç é¢ã§ãè¬åå Žã§ã芪æã察象è ã«é¢äŒã§ããªãç¶æ³ãšãªã£ãŠããããããªäžïŒè£å€æãå°å ¥ããŠãããããªãªã³ã¯ã®ããã«ïŒä»è·æ¯æŽãå«ããŠãªã³ã©ã€ã³é¢äŒãšãã£ãçŽæ¥é¢äŒãé¿ããããžã¿ã«åã®åãçµã¿ãé²ãã§ããã
ãå ç«¥æ¯æŽã§ã¯ãã¬ã¹ã¿ãã£ïŒå°±åŽæ¯æŽã§ã¯ãã¬ã¯ãŒã¯ãšãã£ãããã«ããžã¿ã«åãé²ãã§ããïŒé²è¡çžã¯ç©ççãªåªäœã«å€å決æžããããšã§ïŒãã¬ã¯ãŒã¯ã«æ¬ ããæããããšããŠã·ã¹ãã ãé»å決æžã«å€æŽãããšãã£ãããžã¿ã«åã«ã€ããŠæåã瀺ãããç©ççãªãæçŽããšããéæ¥äº€æµãªã©ãŽã£ã«ã¹ã¯ç©ççåªäœã«ä»çïŒçåãããšãã£ããªã¹ã¯ãçããããšãããïŒå¯©å€ã«æžãããšã¯ãªã¹ã¯ãèæ ®ããŠãããïŒç€ŸäŒç¶æ³ã®å€åãå€æ§åããéã¿ãã°è£å€æã®å®åéçšã¯å€æŽãå¿ èŠã§ãããããžã¿ã«åã®åãçµã¿ã¯æ§ã ãªæ¹é¢ã§ïŒä»ãäžè«ã®æœ®æµã§ããã
ãæ¥æ¬åœæ²æ³ç¬¬ïŒïŒæ¡ã«ãŠåã©ãã®åºæ¬ç人暩ã®äº«æã«ã€ããŠèŠå®ãïŒç¬¬ïŒïŒæ¡ã§ã¯åã©ãã®èªç±æš©åã³äººæš©ãä¿æãã矩åïŒïŒïŒæ¡ã®äººæ Œæš©ïŒå¹žçŠè¿œæ±æš©ããåã©ãã®çåœã»èº«äœã®èªç±ã®ä¿éïŒïŒïŒæ¡ã®åã©ãã®çåæš©ã«ãããå¥åº·ã§æåçãªæäœé床ã®ç掻ã®ä¿éãå®ããããŠããã
芪ã®é€æè²æš©ãšããŠãïŒåïŒïŒæ¡ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ïŒïŒïŒæ¡çã«ãã£ãŠä¿éããïŒå®¶æã®èªåŸãšããŠã¯ïŒåïŒïŒæ¡ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ã§ä¿éãããŠãããã®ãšè§£ããããã€ãŸãåã«å¯Ÿããç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒã¯çŽäºäžã§é«èè€ã®èµ·å ãšãªã£ãŠããŠïŒææè ã®æ¯é åãé«ãŸãåæ©ã§ããããšãåŠå®ãããïŒèªèº«ã§ç掻ãæŽçã§ããªãæªæ幎åãïŒå¿èº«å ±ã«ææããäŸåãåãç¶ããããšãåŠå®ãããªãããšããïŒããããåã®æš©å©ã®äº«æãåŠå®ããïŒåïŒïŒæ¡å¥Žé·çææãšããŠéæ²æ§ãç §ããããã¹ããšããããã
ããã劚害ãæé€ããããã®è«æ±æš©ã代çããæš©å©è ã¯ïŒé¢å©ããŠãé芪暩è ïŒèŠªå¯ãªçŽç³»è¡æïŒã«ãåã®ä¿è·ããæš©å©ãšããŠä»£çæš©ãèªããã¹ãã§ãããä¿è·æš©è ãæ»ãªã©ã«ãã£ãŠåªå€±ããã°ïŒä¿è·æš©è ã®èŠªå¯ãªçŽç³»è¡æã«çžç¶ããããããšãåã®å©çïŒæš©å©ïŒä¿éã®èŠ³ç¹ããæå¹ã§ããããšãåŠå®ãããªãã
ïŒïŒåã®è«æ±æš©ã«ã€ãèªå·±æ±ºå®ã®è©äŸ¡åºæºãïŒïŒæãšããŠèšããã¹ããåŠãã®æ€èš
åã®è«æ±æš©ã«ã¯æç¶ããè«æ±ããæš©å©ïŒé©æ£æªçœ®ãè«æ±ããæš©å©ïŒç£è·ãè«æ±ããæš©å©ïŒèªå·±æ±ºå®ãè«æ±ããæš©å©ïŒãã©ã€ãã·ãŒç¢ºä¿ãè«æ±ããæš©å©ïŒé¢äŒäº€æµããæš©å©ãªã©ãèªããããŠãããé€åçžçµã§ã®è¡çºèœåã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒïŒæ³ãšå®ããããŠããã
åãèªãã®ææã«åããŠèŠªãšäžåœã«åé¢ã匷èŠãããããããšã¯ã粟ç¥çè² æ ã®å€§ãã匷ããããšãã«çžåœãããã€ãŸãéæŸããªããã°ææã®ç¶æ ã¯åºå®ãããïŒåã®å¿èº«ã«å®³ãåãŒãç¶ãããšãããã®ã§ããã
å¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥æé«è£å€æ第äžå°æ³å»·å€æ±ºã§å±±å£åå€äºã¯ããŒã°æ¡çŽã«åºã¥ãèªåææžããé£ãå»ãããšå ¬èšãããæ¯ãšæ®ããäºãéžãã æ¯åã®ææã¯ãïŒïŒæ³ã§åž°åœããŠæ¯èŠªã«äŸåããããåŸãïŒæ¯èŠªã®äžåœãªå¿çç圱é¿ãåããŠãããšèšããããåŸãªãããšããã
äŸåã®äŸãšããŠã¯ïŒèªå·±é²è¡ã®ããã«ãæ°ãããããšããåé¿è¡åããšãããšã¯çç倧åŠã®åæ° æåæ°ïŒäºäž åæ°ïŒçœç³æè¡æ°ã®ææéãç 究ããè«æã§çºè¡šãããŠããã䞡芪ã®çŽäºã«åå ããããªããã©ãŠãããåé¿åå¿ã§ãæ°ããããã®åå¿ã瀺ãïŒäž¡èŠªã«é¢ããæ å ±ãèãå ¥ããïŒéãããšãžç¡æèã«æ°ãåãããããã¯äž¡èŠªã®çŽäºã«å·»ã蟌ãŸããªãããã«ç¡æèã«ãšãé²è¡åå¿ãšèšããã
ããã§èŠªåãäžåœã«åé¢ããå Žåã«ãããŠïŒåã«äžãã粟ç¥ç圱é¿ãåã®çŠç¥ãå©çïŒæš©å©ïŒã«åãïŒå¿ççèåŸ ãšãªãããããšãïŒåã®ç£è·ã«é¢ããæè¿ã®è£å€äŸãåºè»žã«ç€ºãã
ãã¢ïŒèŠªåã®äžåœãªåé¢ã«ãã粟ç¥ç圱é¿
ãïŒ1ïŒèè ã®èŠè§£ïŒå»åŠçèŠå°ïŒ
ãå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒïŒæïŒïŒæ¥æ±äº¬é«è£æ±ºå®ïŒå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒã©ïŒç¬¬ïŒïŒïŒïŒå·ïŒ
ããåãè¡ãé¢äŒäº€æµã«ã€ãåã®å©çïŒæš©å©ïŒã«è³ãããšè©äŸ¡ãããäºå®ã§ã¯ïŒèšŒæ ãšããŠæåºãããå€åœã®æç®çã«ã€ããŠãå¹³æ12幎ãªããå¹³æ13幎é ã«çºè¡šããããããŒãã»ããŠã¶ãŒãã³ã®ãå ±åç£è·ãšåç¬ç£è·ã«ãããåäŸã®é©æ³æ§ã®æ¯èŒã¡ã¿åæå ±åããç §ããïŒ
ãå®è³ªäž(åäŸãããªãã®æéãããã¯ã»ãŒåçã®æéãããããã®èŠªãšéããå Žå)ã»æ³åŸäž(ç芪ãäž»ã«åå± ç£è·ããå Žåã§ïŒä»æ¹ã®èŠªãåäŸã®æè²ãžã®é¢ãããç¶æãïŒåäŸã«é¢ããäºé 決å®ã¯åæ¹ã®èŠªã§è¡ãå Žå)ã®å ±åç£è·äžã«ããåäŸã®é©å¿ç¶æ³ãåç¬ç£è·äžã«ããåäŸã®ãããšæ¯èŒããè«žç 究ã¡ã¿åæãè¡ã£ãçµæïŒå®è³ªäžãããã¯æ³åŸäžã®å ±åç£è·ãåããåäŸã¯ïŒåç¬ç£è·äžã®åäŸãããé©å¿æ§ããã£ããïŒäž¡èŠªã®ããåäŸãšã®éã«ã¯å·®ç°ã¯ã¿ãããªãã£ããç·åçé©å¿ïŒå®¶æé¢ä¿ïŒ èªå°å¿ïŒå¿çïŒè¡åïŒé¢å©çã®åé ç®ãæ¯èŒãããšïŒå ±åç£è·äžã®åäŸã®æ¹ãããããé©å¿æ§ã瀺ããã
ïŒäžç¥ïŒãã®äžæ¹ã§ïŒåå ±åã§ã¯ïŒåè¡åœã§ã¯ã»ãšãã©ã®å·ã§1990幎(å¹³æ2幎)åæãŸã§ã«å ±åç£è·ããªãã·ã§ã³ãšãããå¶åºŠãæ¡çšãããŠããããšïŒäžèšç ç©¶å ±åã®åæãšããŠç 究察象ã®éžåºã«ååãããå¯èœæ§ãåŠå®ã§ããªãããšïŒå ±åç£è·æ¹åŒãéžãã 䞡芪ã¯ïŒé¢å©åãããã¯é¢å©åœæããè¯å¥œãªé¢ä¿ãç¶æã§ããŠããå 倫婊ã§ãããšããïŒå ±åç£è·å®¶åºã®äž¡èŠªã®å¯Ÿç«åºŠãåç¬ç£è·å®¶åºã®ãããããäœãããšããïŒäž¡èŠªã®é¢å©åïŒé¢å©æã®å¯Ÿç«åºŠãã³ã³ãããŒã«ããããšãä»åŸã®ç 究ã®èª²é¡ã§ãããã
ãã®ããã«ç€ºããŠããããã®ããšããïŒåã芪ãšåé¢ã匷èŠããããšïŒèŠªåå ±ã«å¿ççè² æ ãããããšã瀺ãããŠãããçžæ芪ãïŒããåãææãããç¶æ ã§ïŒæ§ã ã«å¶éãããŠããç¶æ ã§å¯Ÿç«ã«æãããšããåé¡ãããïŒããåãå®å¹æ¯é ããïŒåé¢ã匷èŠãããçžæ芪ãã察ç«åºŠã®ã³ã³ãããŒã«ã«ã€ããŠå°é£æ¥µãããããã¯ïŒããåãæåãããŠããåŽã粟ç¥çã«äžå©ãªç«å Žã§ããäºã瀺ããŠãããšããããã
ãã ããããåœã§ã¯ïŒé¢å©æã®åäŸã®èŠªæš©è ã«ã€ããŠã¯åç¬èŠªæš©å¶åºŠãæ¡çšãããŠããïŒ æ¬§ç±³è«žåœãšã¯ããããæ³å¶åºŠãç°ãªãããšããæ確ã«ç€ºãïŒæ¯èŒæ³çèŠå°ã§è©äŸ¡ããŠé ããŠãããã®ã®ããããæ¡çšããããšã¯åºæ¥ãªããããšããŠããïŒãã®æç¹ã§ãšããã³ã¹ã足ããïŒè§£éã«ééãããã£ãŠéåžžã«æ®å¿µã§ããã
ã欧米諞åœã§ã¯ïŒåäŸã«å¯Ÿããäžè¬çãªé€è²æ¹éãªãã芪åé¢ä¿ãšããŠïŒæ©ãå Žåã«ã¯ä¹³å¹Œå ã®é ãã䞡芪ãšã¯å¯å®€ãå¥ã«ãããªã©ïŒå¹Œå°æããåäŸã芪ããé¢ãïŒèŠªãåäŸããé¢ããŠïŒåäŸãæ©æã«èªå·±ã確ç«ããããšãåæãšããŠé€è²ããªãããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒçŸåšã®ããåœã«ãããåäŸã«å¯Ÿããäžè¬çãªé€è²æ¹éãªãã芪åé¢ä¿ãšã¯ç°ãªã£ãŠããã®ãå®æ ã§ããïŒäžèšå ±åã«ãã£ãŠãïŒå ±åç£è·æ¹åŒãæ¡çšããŠããå 倫婊ã¯ïŒé¢å©åãªããé¢å©æããïŒ å€«å©Šéã§ã®å¯Ÿç«ã®åºŠåããäœãã£ããšãããŠããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒãã®ãããªåæãæãã«è«ããããšã¯çžåœã§ã¯ãªããã
ãã®ããã«çç±ã瀺ããŠãããããã§æ¥æ¬ã®å®æ 調æ»ç 究ãç §ããããã
ãã«ãŠã³ã»ãªã³ã°ç 究æçŽèŠãé¢äŒäº€æµã®æç¡ãšèªå·±è¯å®æ/芪åäžå šã®é¢é£/éæšè¡ææïŒå€§æ£å€§åŠèšåºå¿çåŠç§æºææïŒããç §ããã°
ããæ¬ç 究ã®çµæïŒå¥å± 芪ãšé¢äŒäº€æµãããŠããªãåã©ãã¯ïŒãèªå·±è¯å®æããäœããªãïŒã芪åäžå šããé«ããªãããšãæããã«ãªã£ã(泚7)ãäžæ¹ïŒããšã芪ã®é¢å©ãçµéšããåã©ãã§ãã£ãŠãïŒå¥å± 芪ãšé¢äŒäº€æµãç¶ããŠããå ŽåïŒäž¡èŠªã®ããã£ãŠãã家æã®åã©ããšæ¯èŒããŠãèªå·±è¯å®æãããã³ã芪åäžå šãã®åŸç¹ã«å·®ãåºãªãããšãæããã«ãªã£ãããã®çµæã¯ïŒé¢å©åŸãªããå¥å± äžã®åè²ãŠã«ãããé¢äŒäº€æµã®éèŠæ§ãæçœã«ç€ºããŠãããä»åïŒå®¶æ芳ãé¢å©èŠ³ïŒåè²ãŠã«é¢ããæåã®éããè¶ããŠïŒæ¬§ç±³è«žåœã®å è¡ç 究ãšãŸã£ããåæ§ã®çµæãåŸãããããšã¯ïŒéåžžã«éèŠãªæå³ãæã£ãŠãããã»ã»ã»ã
ãã®ããã«çµè«ä»ããŠããã
ãããšãã°ïŒå ±åé€è²ã®æ³å¶åã«åŒŸã¿ãã€ããéåžžã«æåãªWallersteinã(1975ïŒ1980ïŒ 1985ïŒ 1989ïŒ2000)ã®çžŠæçç 究(芪ã®é¢å©ãçµéšããåã©ããã¡ã25幎以äžã«ããã£ãŠè¿œè·¡ãã調æ»)ã«ãããšïŒé¢å©åŸã®ç掻ã«ããé©å¿ãïŒå¿çç¶æ ããã£ãšãè¯å¥œã§ãã£ãã®ã¯ïŒå¥å± 芪ãšå®æçã«é¢äŒäº€æµãæã¡ç¶ããåã©ããã¡ã§ãã£ããéã«ïŒé¢äŒäº€æµãå®æœããªãã£ãå ŽåïŒåã©ãã¯ãèªå·±è¯å®æã®äœäžããåºæ¬çä¿¡é Œæã®äœäž(察人é¢ä¿ã®åé¡)ãã瀟äŒçäžé©å¿ããæãã€ãããã©ãã°/ã¢ã«ã³ãŒã«äŸåçããé¢å©ãç芪çå€ã®äžä»£éé£éãçã§èŠããããšãå ±åãããŠãã(BakerïŒ 2007)ãã»ã»ã»ã
ãããããäžèšçµè«ã¯Wallersteinãã®25幎以äžã«ããã£ãŠè¿œè·¡ãã調æ»ãšæ¯èŒããŠç€ºãããã®ã§ããïŒç 究è ã®ããŒã¿ã«åºã¥ãæå¹ãªãšããã³ã¹ã§ãã£ãŠæé€ã§ããªãã
ããã»ã©ãŸã§ã«èŠªåäžåé¢ã®ååã«åºã¥ãåãšèŠªã«æããèªç¶æš©ã®ä¿éãéèŠããïŒç 究çµæãå¢ããŠããã®ã¯ïŒäž¡èŠªåæ¹ãšã®ãæ¥åžžçãªæ ç·äº€æµããåã©ãã®å¥å šãªäººæ Œåœ¢æã«æ¬ ãããªããšããå®èšŒçç¥èŠãèç©ãããŠããããã§ããã
ã€ãŸãå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒïŒæïŒïŒæ¥æ±äº¬é«è£æ±ºå®ïŒå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒã©ïŒç¬¬ïŒïŒïŒïŒå·ã§ç€ºããããåãè¡ãé¢äŒäº€æµã«ã€ãåã®å©çïŒæš©å©ïŒã«è³ãããšè©äŸ¡ããã決å®ã®äžã§ããããæ¡çšããããšã¯åºæ¥ãªããããšã®å€æã®åã«ïŒéæšè¡ææïŒå€§æ£å€§åŠèšåºå¿çåŠç§æºææïŒã®ç 究çµæããšããã³ã¹ãšããŠç€ºãããŠããã°è©äŸ¡ãå€ãã£ãŠããããšãåŠå®ãããªãã
ãç芪çå€ãã«é¢ããå®æ 調æ»ç 究ã/éæšè¡ææïŒå€§æ£å€§åŠèšåºå¿çåŠç§æºææïŒã§ã¯
ãã»ã»ã»ä»åã®èª¿æ»ã«ãããŠïŒé¢äŒäº€æµãªã矀ã¯é¢äŒäº€æµãã矀ãšæ¯èŒããŠïŒ
ã»ãç¥çµçåŸåããé«ãã
ã»ãèªæèããšãå·ã€ããããããé«ãã
ã»ãçŸ€å± æ§ããäœãããšããçµæãåŸãããã
äžæ¹ïŒé¢äŒäº€æµãã矀ã¯é¢äŒäº€æµãªã矀ãšæ¯èŒããŠïŒ
ã»ã審çŸæ§ããé«ãããšããçµæãåŸãããã
ãã®çµæããïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã®æç¡ãåã©ãã«äžãã圱é¿ã®äžç«¯ãå£éèŠãããšãã§ãããä»åïŒé¢äŒäº€æµãªã矀ã«ã¿ããããã€ãã¹é¢ã®åœ±é¿ã ãã§ãªãïŒé¢äŒäº€æµãã矀ã«ã審çŸæ§ãã®é«ããšãããã©ã¹é¢ã®åœ±é¿ãã¿ãããããšã¯ïŒä»åŸã®ç 究ã«æããå±æãäžããŠãããã»ã»ã»ã
é¢å©åŸã®é€è²åé¡ãšé¢æ¥äº€æž(å¥å± åãšèŠªã®é¢äŒäº€æµ)ã«é¢ããç 究/éæšè¡ææïŒå€§æ£å€§åŠèšåºå¿çåŠç§æºææïŒã§ã¯ïŒ
ãã»ã»ã»é¢äŒäº€æµã®é »åºŠãæžããšèŠªåé¢ä¿ãçé ã«ãªãïŒåã©ãã®æé·ã«åœ±é¿ãåºãããšã確èªãããŠããã»ã»ã»ã
ãã®ããã«èª¿æ»çµæãã芪ãšåé¢ãããŠããåã©ãã«äžããå¿çç圱é¿ãææãããŠããã
å¹³æ25幎7æ3æ¥æ±äº¬é«è£æ±ºå®ïŒå€ã¿1393å·233é ïŒ
ãåã¯ïŒåå± ããŠããªã芪ãšã®é¢äŒäº€æµãåæ»ã«å®æœãããããšã«ããïŒã©ã¡ãã®èŠªãããæãããŠãããšããå®å¿æãåŸãããšãã§ããããããã£ãŠïŒå€«å©Šã®äžåã«ããå¥å± ã«äŒŽããã®åªå€±æãããã«ããäžå®å®ãªå¿çç¶æ³ãå埩ããïŒå¥å šãªæé·ãå³ãããã«ïŒãæªæ幎è ã®çŠç¥ã害ããçé¢äŒäº€æµãå¶éãã¹ãç¹æ®µã®äºæ ããªãéããïŒé¢äŒäº€æµãå®æœããŠããã®ãããã»ã»ã»ã
ãã®ããã«åã®å¥å± ã«äŒŽããã®åªå€±æãäžå®å®ã«ãªãå¿çç¶æ³ã瀺ããŠããã
æ°Žéæåè£å€å®ã»äžéæŽè¡è£å€å®ïŒç¬¬6å é¢äŒäº€æµã®èª¿åã»å¯©å€äºä»¶ã®å¯©çïŒæ³æ¹æå ±66å·»ïŒå·ïŒé ïŒïŒå¹³æ26幎ïŒæïŒ
ãç¶æ¯ãé¢å©åã¯å¥å± ããŠãïŒåã«ãšã£ãŠã¯èŠªã§ããããšã«å€ããã¯ãªãïŒéç£è·èŠªããã®ææ ãæããããããšãåã®å¥å šãªæé·ã®ããã«éèŠã§ãããé¢äŒäº€æµãå®çŸããããšã§ïŒé¢å©ãå¥å± ã«ããåã®æ²ãã¿ãåªå€±æã軜æžãããããšãæåŸ ã§ããã
ãããŠæ°æ³æ¹æ£ã®ç«æ³ã®çµç·¯ã«ãããŠãïŒåã®é€è²ã»å¥å šãªæé·ã®é¢ãããïŒäžè¬çã«ã¯èŠªãšã®æ¥è§Šãç¶ç¶ããããšãæãŸããïŒå¯èœãªéã家åºè£å€æã¯èŠªåã®é¢äŒãã§ããããã«åªããããšãæ°æ³766æ¡ã®æå³ãããšãããšãããŠããã»ã»ã»ã
ãã®ããã«ç€ºããŠãããåã®æ²ãã¿ãåªå€±æã«ã€ããŠã¯è¿å¹Žçºè¡šãããŠãããã¹çå矀ã«é¡ããïŒæ§çç¶ïŒã§ãããšè§£ããããããããã¹ãè¿èŠªè ãã¹ã«ããåªå€±æã¯å¿çç圱é¿ã倧ããïŒåºæ¬çã«ã¯æ»ãç解ããŠã°ãªãŒãïŒæ²åïŒãã±ã¢ããŠããããšãå¿ççæ³ãšããŠã®è§£æ±ºçã§ãããïŒäžåœãªèŠªåã®åé¢ã¯ïŒçããŠããŠïŒãã€ã§ãäŒããã¯ããïŒäŒããããŠãäŒããªããšãã£ãå¿ã®è² æ ãçãïŒæ»ãå²ãåãããšãåºæ¥ãçæéã§ã®ãæéãã«ãã解決ãæ±ããããšãåºæ¥ãïŒåé¢ã匷èŠããã芪åã¯å ±ã«ïŒãã絶倧ãªå¿çè² æ ã匷ããããããšã¯ç¡èŠã§ããªãã
ãªããªãïŒåžžã«ãã°ã«ãããããããè¿èŠªè ãäœããã®çç±ã§æåã«ããã°ïŒãã®åªå€±æã¯ïŒæ人ã§ããã°æçå·å®³ãæ人æãåŒãèµ·ãã圱é¿ã®åå ãšãªã£ããããããšãææãããŠããããã§ããããŸããŠãïŒèŠªåãåé¢ããããŸãŸïŒã©ã¡ããã®æ»ã«ãã£ãŠé¢ä¿ãæ¶å€±ããã°ïŒæš©å©ä¿éã«å€§ããåããã®ã§ããã
åªå€±ã«ãããã¹çå矀ãªã©ããããã¹ãè¿èŠªè ãã¹ä»¥å€ã«ãæ¥æ¬ã§ã¯ãã§ã«æ人æãªã©åŸçºæ§ã®çºéé害æ§çç¶ã¯èªç¥ãããŠãããå ç«¥ãçªç¶ïŒä»æ¹èŠªããã¹ããŠç²Ÿç¥çã¹ãã¬ã¹ããçºçãã粟ç¥çãã¡ãŒãžã¯å ç«¥çŠç¥æ³ïŒå ç«¥èåŸ é²æ¢æ³ãªã©ã®èŠ³ç¹ãã粟ç¥çãã¡ãŒãžã劚害ãšããŠç §ããé©æ£æªçœ®ïŒåŠšå®³æé€ïŒãæ±ããæªæ幎åã®æš©å©ã¯å¹Žéœ¢ãåãã¹ãã§ã¯ãªãããšãåããã
ãé¢å©æ¯âç芪çå€ãšããå ç«¥èåŸ ãã®èè ãªãã£ãŒãã»A-ãŠã©ãŒã·ã£ãã¯ã®æžããSTEMMIG THE TIDE OF MISINFORMATION:INTERNATIONAL CONSENSUS ON SHARED PARENTING AND OVERNIGHTINïŒ2017ïŒãšããè«æãã
ãã¡ã¿ã¢ããªã·ã¹ã¯ïŒäž¡èŠªéã®èè€ã®ã¬ãã«ã«ãããããïŒåç¬ç£è·ã®åã©ããšæ¯èŒããŠïŒå ±åç£è·ã®åã©ãã§ã¯ïŒææ çïŒè¡åçïŒããã³åŠè¡çæ©èœãããããã£ãããšãå ±åããŠããŸã( A meta-analysis reported better emotionalïŒ behavioralïŒ and academic functioning for children in joint physical custody compared to children in sole custodyïŒ regardless of the level of conflict between parents.)ã
芪ã®èè€ã«ããæ害ãªåœ±é¿ãæ¡å€§ããã®ã§ã¯ãªãïŒããã€ãã®ç 究ã¯ïŒå ±åé€è²ãçŽäºã®æœåšçãªè² ã®çµæããåã©ããå®ããããããªãããšã瀺åããŠãã(Rather than magnify harmful effects of parental conflictïŒ several studies suggested that joint physical custody may protect children from some of the potential negative consequences of conflict. )ã
ãããïŒå ±åç£è·ãããŠããåã©ãã¯ïŒåç¬ç£è·ãããŠããåã©ãã«æ¯ã¹ãŠïŒ èè€ã¯ããã»ã©å€§ããªæ害ãäžããŸãããçŽäºã¯ïŒå ±åç£è·ã®å©çãæ¶å»ããŸãã(But conflict is not more damaging for children in joint physical custody than those in sole custody. Conflict does not erase the benefits of joint custody.)ã
ããŒã«ã»ã³ã¯ïŒè¯å®çãªçµæãäºæž¬ããã«ããã£ãŠã¯ïŒäœèè€ãå調çãªå ±åé€è²ããã質ã®é«ã芪åé¢ä¿ãéèŠã§ããããšãèŠåºããŸãã(Nielsen found that in predicting positive outcomesïŒ high quality parent- child relationships are more important than low conflict or cooperative co-parenting.)ã
ãããŠïŒè³ªã®é«ãé¢ä¿æ§ç¯ã«ã¯ïŒçºéãšç¹æ ã®ããã«ååãªæéãå¿ èŠã§ã(And high quality relationships need sufficient time to develop and flourish.)ã
倫婊ããé«èè€ããšææããããšãã«ïŒäžæ¹ã®åãšèŠªã©ãã®æéãèªåçã«å¶éãããšããæ¹éã¯ïŒåã©ããšäžæ¹ã®èŠªãšã®é¢ä¿æ§æ§ç¯ãšããä¿è·ç·©è¡ã奪ããšããåé¡ãçããããŸã(A policy of automatically restricting childrenâs time with one of the parents when a couple is labeled as âhigh conflictâ brings additional drawbacks and deprives children of the protective buffer of a nurturing relationship with one of their parents.)ã
ãã®æ¹éã¯ïŒèè€ãäœãã ãïŒãŸãã¯ç¶æããããšãå ±å芪暩ãç¡å¹ã«ããå¹æçãªæŠç¥ã§ãããšããã¡ãã»ãŒãžã䞡芪ã«éããŸã (This policy sends parents the message that generating or sustaining conflict can be an effective strategy to override shared custody.)ã
ããã¯ïŒåžæ°ã®ã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ãšååãéªéãïŒæããå°ãªã䞡芪ã®èè€ããåã©ããå®ãïŒäž¡èŠªãšã®ç©æ¥µçãªé¢ä¿ã®å¿ èŠæ§ãèªèãæ¯æŽããåãšèŠªã©ããšã®æéãæžããå¯èœæ§ããããŸã(This discourages civil communication and cooperationïŒ and may reduce childrenâs time with the parent who is less angryïŒ who does a better job of shielding the children from conflictïŒ and who recognizes and supports the childrenâs need for positive relationships with both parents.)ã ã
以äžã®ããã«ïŒåå± èŠªãé«èè€ã§ãããšäž»åŒµãïŒãã®ããšãçç±ã«èŠªååçµ±åïŒèŠªåæ§ç¯ïŒãæãïŒãããã¯åæžãæ±ãïŒãããèªããããå Žåã«ã¯ïŒçžæ芪ã«å¯ŸãæåŠèªäœãçç±ã«ïŒãã€ãŸã§ãé«èè€ã§ãããšäž»åŒµãç¶ããã°ãããšãããªããããïŒäžæ¹ã®åãšèŠªã©ãã®èŠªåæ§ç¯ã®æéãå¶éããæ¹éããŸããéããªãããã«ãïŒçžåœã§ã¯ãªãããšã瀺ããŠããã®ã§ããã
ã€ãŸãçŸã«ç¶æ¯éã«èè€ããã£ãŠãïŒãããã¯ãã®èè€ãé«ããšè©äŸ¡ãããå Žåã§ãã£ãŠãåã®ç²Ÿç¥çã¹ãã¬ã¹ãèæ ®ããã°ïŒç¹æ®µã®é倧ãªçç±ããªããã°ïŒå ±åç£è·ã芪ååçµ±åïŒèŠªåæ§ç¯ïŒãå¶éãããã¹ãã§ã¯ãªãã
ãŠã©ãŒã·ã£ãã¯(2012)ã®ç 究ããèªã¿è§£ãã°ïŒäž¡èŠªã®æ¿ããèè€ã«æãããããšã«ããå·ã€ãã®æ·±ããèãããšïŒå Žåã«ãã£ãŠã¯çæ¹ã®èŠªãšãã®èŠªæãšã®èŠªåã®æ絶ãïŒãããåŸãªããšèãã人ãå°ãªãããååšãããããããèãã®è£å€å®ã調æ»å®ã¯ïŒèè€ã®åé¿ã第äžçŸ©çã«æåã§ãããšèããŠãããšãããã
ãããæªæ幎åãäž»äœã«èå¯ããã°ïŒãã¡ãã䞡芪ã®äºãã¯åã©ãã®å®å¿æã幞ããæã¡ã®ããããšã«ãªããïŒã ãããšãã£ãŠèŠªã®æåŠèªäœãçç±ã«é¢å¥æ絶åé¢ããŸããéã£ãŠããŸãïŒèŠªãšã®äº€æµã倱ãããšã¯ïŒåã©ãã«æŽã«å³ãã倧ããªææãäžããããšã«ãªãããšã¯èšããŸã§ããªãã幞çŠè¿œæ±æš©ã®è¶£æšã§ããäººæ Œæš©ãéã¿ãã°ïŒãããåŸãªããšããçç±ã§è§£æ±ºã«è³ãããããšã¯æããã«å€±åœã§ãããã
芪åé¢ä¿ã芪æãšã®äº€æµãåŒãè£ãããåã©ãã¯ïŒãã®å·ãçããããšãåºæ¥ããåŠãïŒããã¯æ人æã®çç¶ãå°æ¥ïŒçºçãããããªãããèŠæ¥µãããŸã§åãããªãïŒæãã¯ç芪çå€ã«ããåŒãããããéè¡ã«èµ°ããŸã§ç¥ãç±ããªãããïŒãããŸã§ãªã¹ã¯ãäºæ³åºæ¥ãŠãè©äŸ¡åºæ¥ãªããšããäºã«ãªããåŸã£ãŠïŒäž¡èŠªã®äºãã®äœæ³¢ããåã©ããå®ãããã«ããããããšãè©Šã¿ã€ã€ïŒèŠªåé¢ä¿ãç¶æããããšãåã®çŠç¥ãšããŠç€ŸäŒãåççè£éæš©ã®è¶£æšã§ããã芪ååçµ±åãã«åŸã£ãŠåãçµãã¹ããšãããã
ã€ãŸã芪ã®é«èè€ã芪ãšåã®èªç¶æš©ãå¶éããæ ¹æ ãšã¯ãªããªããšãããã
ãã®æ ¹æ ã¯ïŒ2.é¢äŒäº€æµ(å ±åé€è²)ã®éèŠæ§ãšç§åŠçã»å¿çåŠçæ ¹æ
(1)é£ãå»ããšåŒãé¢ãã¯ãã©ãŠãã«ãªãå¯èœæ§ãé«ãã
(2)é¢å©ãå¥å± ã®åã«äžãã圱é¿ãæãã
(3)幌ãåã©ãã¯ïŒçæ¹ã®èŠªã«ãã£ãŠéäžçã«ç£è·ãããã¹ãã
(5)ç芪çå€(ç芪çå€çå矀)ã®ãªã¹ã¯
ãããã®ç 究ãå«ããŠè©äŸ¡ããŠããã®ã§ããã
ããããã®è©äŸ¡ã¯ïŒïŒ(5)ãç£è·èŠªã«æ±ããããé¢äŒäº€æµã«å¯Ÿããæ 床ããš(6)ä»æ¹åãšèŠªãšã®é¢ä¿æ§ãç¶æã»ä¿é²ãããç©æ¥µçæ 床ããç §ããã°ïŒåãäŸåã«ãã£ãŠææãæããªããšãïŒäžèªç±ã®åŒ·èŠããéæŸãæ±ããææãããã°ïŒãã®ç¶æ ãåºå®ãããªãããšãè©äŸ¡ããã°ããŠã¯ãŸãã
ãããã§ç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒãè¯å®ããåžæ³éçšãæ£åœãšè©äŸ¡ããããªãã°ïŒããã¯åç¬èŠªæš©å¶åºŠã®äœæ³¢ãåŠå®ã§ããªãã®ã§ããã
ããããç£è·è ãäžæ¹ã«ããªããã°ãªããªããšãã£ãæ³ã®ææã¯ç¡ãïŒå ±å芪暩äžãé¢å©åŸã®åç¬èŠªæš©æå®åŸãå ±åç£è·ã¯ç¹æ®µã®çç±ãªãåŠå®ãããªãã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒãããææããªããŸãŸã«å ±åç£è·ãè¯å®ããªãåé ããïŒæ¬§ç±³ã§ã®åç¬èŠªæš©éæ²èšŽèšã§ç §ããããææè ã®æ¯é ã®åŽé¢ïŒæãã¯åŒ·ããåœå ã«ãããŠè©äŸ¡ãããåã®å©çã«å®³ãææãããŠãããïŒå®åéçšãšããŠèãã«ãªã£ãŠãããšãããã®ã§ããã
ã€ãŸãåç¬ç£è·äžã§è²ã€åãïŒé芪暩è ã«ç£è·ãè«æ±ãããïŒå ç«¥çžè«æã«é©æ£æªçœ®ãè«æ±ãããïŒåã©ãã®æç¶ã代ç人ã«æç¶ããè«æ±ãããïŒå ç«¥çžè«æãåŠæ ¡ã§ã®å人ã®ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒãæ±ããïŒæ§ã ãªæªæ幎åã®è«æ±ããæš©å©ã¯ïŒå¹Žéœ¢ã«åãããä¿éãããã¹ãæ ¹æ ãããã
ãïŒ2ïŒèè ã®èŠè§£ïŒå®åçèŠå°ïŒ
é·å¹ŽïŒå ¬çã«é¢äŒäº€æµæ¯æŽãè¡ã£ãŠããå£äœã®ïŒŠïŒ°ïŒ©ïŒ£ã®ãåã©ããäž»äººå ¬ã®é¢äŒäº€æµïŒ1ïŒãšããè³æãç §ãããŠãïŒããããè¡šé¡ããããŠãåã©ããäž»äººå ¬ããšãªã£ãŠãããã€ãŸãç£è·èŠªã®èè€ãåå ã§åãåé¢ã匷èŠãããããšèªäœã«ééããããã
ãããŠãïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã®ç©¶æ¥µã®ç®çãã«ãåã©ãã¯ç¶æ¯ã®ææ ãåããªããïŒç¶æ¯ãã¢ãã«ã«ããŠæé·ããŸããã²ãšã€å±æ ¹ã®äžã«æ®ãããŠããªããŠãïŒèªåã«ã¯äž¡èŠªããããšããããšãå®æããªããè²ã€ããšãåã©ãã«å€§ããªåãäžããŸãã
é¢äŒäº€æµã®ç©¶æ¥µã®ç®çã¯ïŒåã芪ãç¥ãïŒãã®èŠªã®ææ ã確èªããŠå®å¿ããŠè²ã€ããšã«ãããŸããããšæèšãïŒ
ãâŽãåã©ãã芪ãç¥ãæš©å©ã®å®çŸãã«ã¯ãåã©ãã®æš©å©æ¡çŽïŒ7 æ¡ïŒã«ããããšããïŒèŠªãç¥ãæš©å©ã¯ïŒäž»äœã§ããåã©ãã®æš©å©ã§ãã芪ã¯åã©ãããã®äžã«ååšããã«ãŒãã§ããïŒåã©ããïŒèªåã¯äœè ã§ããããšããèªæïŒã»ã«ãã¢ã€ãã³ãã£ãã£ïŒã確ç«ããããã®åå°ã§ããã
ãâµ çå¿ããããŠææ ãäŒããããã®åã«å¯Ÿããè©«ã³ãã«ã¯ãå€ãã®èŠªã¯ïŒèªåããã被害è ã ãšæã£ãŠããŸããïŒé¢å©ã«ãã£ãŠãã£ãšãã€ããæããããã®ã¯èŠªã§ã¯ãªãïŒåã©ãã§ããããšã
ãïŒã代æ¿ãåããªãç¶æ¯ã®åºæã®åœ¹å²ããšããŠãç¶æ¯ã«ã¯ãã¯ã代æ¿ãåããªãåºæã®åœ¹å²ããããããšããŠããã
ã€ãŸãç£è·ã«é¢ãããã®ãããïŒåã®å¿çãããéã¿ãŠã±ã¢ãã¹ãã§ããããããïŒåã«ãšã£ãŠå šã足ããŠããªãç¶æ³äžã«çœ®ãããŠãããšããã¹ãã§ããã
倧éªå®¶å¯©å¹³æ5幎12æ22æ¥å®¶æ47å·»4å·45é
ãåã©ãã¯ãäººæ Œã®å®æããããïŒå¿èº«ã®å¥å šãªçºéãæ±ããåºæ¬ç人暩ãä¿éãããã°ãªããªã(æ²æ³ç¬¬ïŒïŒæ¡ç¬¬ïŒé ïŒ æè²åºæ¬æ³ç¬¬ïŒæ¡)ã
ïŒäžç¥ïŒäººæ Œã®åæºãªçºéã«äžå¯æ¬ ãªäž¡èŠªã®æè²ã®äº«åãæ±ããåã®æš©å©ãšããŠã®æ§è³ªããæããã
ãã®ããã«æ§æãããŠããããšããïŒåºæ¬ç人暩ã®ä¿éã®ã¿ãªããïŒäººæ Œã®åæºãªçºéã«äžå¯æ¬ ãªäž¡èŠªã®æè²ã®äº«åãæ±ããããšãåºæ¥ïŒæèŠè¡šæïŒèªå·±æ±ºå®ïŒã«ãã£ãŠé©æ£æªçœ®ïŒåŠšå®³æé€ïŒãæ±ããããšã¯åŠ¥åœã§ããã
æ±äº¬å®¶å¯©å¹³æ18幎7æ31æ¥å®¶æ59å·»3å·73é
ãäžè¬ã«ïŒç¶æ¯ãé¢å©ããå ŽåãïŒæªæçåãéç£è·èŠªãšé¢äŒäº€æµã®æ©äŒãæã¡ïŒèŠªããã®ææ ã泚ãããããšã¯ïŒåã®å¥å šãªæé·ïŒäººæ Œåœ¢æã®ããã«å¿ èŠãªããšã§ããïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã®å®æœãåã®çŠç¥ã«åãããªã©ã®ç¹æ®µã®äºæ ããªãéãïŒãããèªããã®ãæãŸãããã
ãã®ããã«ç€ºããïŒèŠªããã®ææ ã泚ãããããšã¯ïŒåã®å¥å šãªæé·ïŒäººæ Œåœ¢æã®ããã«å¿ èŠãšããŠç€ºãããŠããããšããéã¿ãã°ïŒæªæ幎åã¯èŠªããã®ææ ã泚ãããããšã«æ¬ ãããšãããçããã®ã§ããïŒåã®å¥å šãªæé·ïŒäººæ Œåœ¢æã«å®³ãçããŠããŠïŒé©æ£æªçœ®ïŒåŠšå®³æé€ïŒãæ±ããæš©å©ãè©äŸ¡ãããã¹ãã§ããã
ãã㧠é«æ©æµåïŒèå¿å¥³å倧åŠåèªææïŒä»ç·šã人éé¢ä¿ã(2012幎)ãçºéç§åŠå ¥é[2]èå æïœå ç«¥æã(æ±äº¬å€§åŠåºçäŒ) 165é ïŒ177é
ãåã©ããšå¥å± 芪ãšã®é¢äŒäº€æµã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒåã©ãã®çºéæé·ã«ãšã£ãŠå¥å± 芪ãšé¢ããããšã極ããŠéèŠã§ããã
ãåã©ãã®äººæ Œåœ¢æ(粟ç¥ã®åœ¢æ)ã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒå¿çåŠã®äžçã§ã¯ïŒæ°çå æã»ä¹³å æã»å¹Œå æã»å ç«¥æã»ææ¥æã»é幎æãçµãŠèªç¥èœåïŒä»è ãšã®é¢ä¿åœ¢æç¶æèœåïŒæ ç·ã®å®å®èœåãªã©ã段éçã«èº«ã«ã€ããŠããã
ãç¹ã«ïŒåã©ãã®å¿è±¡ã®åœ¢æéçšãäººæ Œã®åœ¢æéçšã«ãããŠç¶æ¯ãšã®é¢ãããïŒå®å®ããåã©ãã®ç²Ÿç¥ãäººæ Œã«åœ±é¿ãããšèãããïŒãŸãïŒäººéé¢ä¿ã«é¢ããå¿çæ çµã¿ã¯ç°å¢ã«ãã£ãŠåœ±é¿ãããã€ã€æéã®çµéã®äžã§å€å®¹ããŠãããšè§£ãããŠãããã
ãã®ããã«ç€ºããŠããïŒç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒã¯ïŒåã®äººæ Œåœ¢æã«ãããéåžžã«éèŠãªææã«ãåã©ãã®ç²Ÿç¥ãäººæ Œã«å®å®ããªããŸãŸåœ±é¿ãããŠãããã®ããšè§£ããã®ã§ããã
ãåã©ãããèŠãé¢äŒäº€æµ/å°ç°åçŽåïŒæ¥åŒé£ãèªç±ãšæ£çŸ©ãïŒ12æå·ïŒ60å·»12å·28é ã䞡芪ã®é¢å©ã»å¥å± ã®éã®é¢äŒäº€æµã®åé¡ç¹ãšèª²é¡ãç¹éïŒ
ãå¿ èŠã«å¿ããŠåã©ããšé¢ããïŒåã©ãã®çºéãæ¯ããããšãã§ããããããŠïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã¯ïŒåã©ãããâ 芪ããæãããŠããããšã®ç¢ºèªïŒâ¡èŠªé¢ãã®ä¿é²â¢ã¢ã€ãã³ãã£ãã£ã®ç¢ºç«ããå®çŸããããã«å¿ èŠãªäžæ段ãšèšããã ãããåã©ãããéç£è·èŠªãšã®äº€æµãç¶ç¶ããããšã¯ïŒåã©ãã粟ç¥çãªå¥åº·ãä¿ã¡ïŒå¿ççã»ç€ŸäŒçãªé©å¿ãæ¹åããããã«éèŠããªã®ã§ãããå€ãã®å ŽåïŒå¥å± 芪ã¯ç¶èŠªã§ãããïŒå©å§»ç¶ç¶äžã®ç¶æ¯ã察象ã«ããç 究ã§ã¯ïŒç¶èŠªã®é¢äžãåã©ãã®çºè²ã«å¥œãŸãã圱é¿ã»ã»ã»
ïŒäžç¥ïŒçºéããéçšã«ãããŠèŠªãšã®é¢ãããæç¶ããããšãåã©ãã® äººæ Œã圢æãæ æãæ·±ããçµæãããããã®ã§ããïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã¯åã©ãã® å¥å šãªæé·ãäººæ Œåœ¢æ極ããŠéèŠãªãã®ã»ã»ã»
ïŒäžç¥ïŒè£å€æããåã¯ïŒç¶æ¯åæ¹ãšäº€æµããããšã«ããäººæ Œçã«æé·ããŠããã®ã§ããããïŒåã«ãšã£ãŠã¯ïŒå©å§»é¢ä¿ãç Žç¶»ããŠç¶æ¯ãå¥å± ããåŸãïŒ ç¶æ¯åæ¹ãšã®äº€æµãç¶æããããšãã§ããç£è·ç°å¢ãæãŸããããšã¯æããã§ããïŒæ±äº¬é«æ±ºå¹³æ15幎1æ20æ¥å®¶æ56å·»4å·127é ïŒãïŒãåãšéç£è·èŠªãšã®é¢äŒäº€æµã¯ïŒåãéç£è·èŠªããæãããŠããããšãç¥ãæ©äŒãšããŠïŒåã®å¥å šãªæé·ã«ãšã£ãŠéèŠãªæ矩ãããïŒå€§éªé«æ±ºå¹³æ21幎1æ16æ¥å®¶æ61å·»11å·70é ïŒããéç£è·èŠªã®åã«å¯Ÿããé¢äŒäº€æµã¯ïŒåºæ¬çã«ã¯ïŒåã®å¥å šè²æã«æçãªãã®ãšããããšãã§ããïŒå€§éªé«æ±ºå¹³æ18幎2æ3æ¥å®¶æ58å·»11å·47é ïŒããªã©ãšèª¬æããŠããïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã¯åã©ãã®çºéãšã®é¢ä¿ã§éèŠãããŠããã»ã»ã»
ïŒäžç¥ïŒåã©ãã¯å¿èº«ãšãã«æ¥ã çºéãããšããåã©ãã«é¢ããåçãªèªèã«åºã¥ããŠïŒåã©ããšå¥å± 芪ãšã®ç¶ç¶çãªé¢ãããéèŠã§ãããšããïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã¯ãã®é¢ããã®äžã€ãšããŠäœçœ®ä»ããããŠãããã
ãã®ããã«ç€ºããŠããã芪åæ§ç¯ïŒèŠªåã®åçµ±åïŒãå¶éããããšïŒåã«ãšã£ãŠäººæ Œçãªæé·ã«å®³ãåãŒãïŒæãããŠããããšãç¥ãæ©äŒã奪ããïŒå¥å šãªæé·ã«ãšã£ãŠåŠšããšãªãææç¶æ ãç¶ããšãããã®ã§ãããã€ãŸãåã¯çŸåšïŒäººæ Œã®åæºãªçºéã«äžå¯æ¬ ãªäž¡èŠªã®æè²ã®äº«åãæ±ããããšãåºæ¥ãŠãããïŒåèªèº«ã§å®¹æã«æŽçã§ããããžã¿ã«éä¿¡ããå¶éãããŠããïŒåã¯å¿èº«ãšãã«æ¥ã çºéãã幌å°ã®æéã«ã€ãçŸç°å¢ã¯å¥å šè²æã«æ害ãªãã®ãšãªã£ãŠããã
ããã§åã®äººæ Œã®å®æãç®æãïŒå¿èº«ã®å¥å šãªçºéãæ±ããåºæ¬ç人暩ãä¿éãããªããã°ãªããªããåŸã£ãŠèŠªåã®èªç¶æš©ã¯åœç¶ã«ä¿éãããã¹ããšãããã®ã§ãã£ãŠåã®åæºãªçºéã«éèŠãªæ矩ã«åããŠããããšã¯æ確ã§ããã
ãäžèšïŒã®ãšïŒã«ç€ºãããïŒåã¯ïŒèªèº«ã§å®¹æã«æŽçã§ããé»åéä¿¡ã·ã¹ãã ïŒãã¬ãé»è©±ïŒïŒ³ïŒ®ïŒ³ïŒïŒ³ïŒïŒ³ïŒã¡ãŒã«ãªã©ïŒã®å©çšãå¶éãããããšãªãïŒèº«äžç£è·è ã粟ç¥çã±ã¢ããã¹ãã§ãã£ãŠïŒåã®æš©å©ã劚ããããŠããå Žåã«ã¯ïŒæ¥ã å¿èº«ãšãã«çºéãã幌å°ã®æéã«ãããŠïŒåã®å¥å šãªçºéïŒè²æïŒæè²ã¯å®³ãããŠããããšã¯æããã§ãããåãã³ããã«ææããã芪ãã³ããã«ææããŠãïŒèŠªåãåé¢ããããŸãŸç³ãäŒããããšãªãç¥ãããšãåºæ¥ãªããªã©ïŒç²Ÿç¥ã®å®å®ãä¿ã€ã¹ãïŒãã®æãã人暩ã䟵害ãããŠãããšãã以äžïŒä»ã«ãªãã
ææšæµåïŒæ±äº¬å¥³å倧åŠåèªææïŒã倧人ãè²ã€æ¡ä»¶äžçºéå¿çåŠããèããã126é (2013幎)ã寺èãããïŒåŒç倧åŠåã©ãåŠ(åã©ãç°å¢åŠ)ïŒç涯çºéçè·åŠåææïŒãåè²ãŠã«ãã芪圹å²éææãšèŠªã®å¿ççãªçºéãšã®é¢é£æ§ãå°å ä¿å¥ç 究69å·»1å·47ïœ50é
ãåãšé¢äŒäº€æµã§ããªãå¥å± 芪ã®å¿çç圱é¿ã¯å€§ããã
ãã®ããã«å¥å± 芪åŽã®ç²Ÿç¥çè² æ ã瀺ããŠããããã®åŒçšãéã¿ãŠãåãšèŠªãåé¢åŒ·èŠãããéã«ãããå¿çç圱é¿ã¯èŠªååæ¹å ±ã«å€§ããããšãããããè¿èŠªè ãã¹çå矀ãçåã®åªå€±ã¯ãäºãã«èŠªåé¢ä¿ãåžèåããŠããïŒãããåªå€±ããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒåã«éå®ããããã®ã§ã¯ãªãïŒãŸãå¥å± 芪ã«ã ãéå®ããããã®ã§ã¯ãªããã€ãŸã芪åäžåé¢ã®ååã¯ïŒèŠªåã®èªç¶æš©ãšããŠèŠªååæ¹ã«éèŠããããïŒèª°ãäžåœã«åŠšããããšã¯åºæ¥ãªãã®ã§ããã
ãã®ããã«èŠªåäžåé¢ã®ååã«åºã¥ã芪ãšåã®èªç¶æš©ãïŒåççã«éèŠæ§ã瀺ãããŠããããšããç §ããã°ïŒäž¡èŠªããææ ãåãïŒãŸãç¶æ§åçååŸæãã¯æ¯æ§åçç¿åŸã®ã©ã¡ããã«æ¬ ããæãããã°ïŒåã®å¥å šãªæé·ïŒäººæ Œåœ¢æã«å®³ãçããããšãæçœã§ããããïŒåãäž»äœãšãã¹ãéçšã®äžã§ïŒããã«åã®æš©å©ãå°éããŠããããšã«ã€ãïŒåã®å¹Žéœ¢ã«åãããããšã¯åã®å©çã«è³ãããªãéçšã§ãããšããã¹ãã§ããã
ã€ïŒåå¥ã®ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒã«ã€ããŠ
æ£ç¬åéåŒè·å£«ïŒäžå€®å€§åŠæ³ç§å€§åŠé¢ææïŒäº¬éœå€§åŠå€§åŠé¢æ³åŠç 究ç§ææïŒïŒã䞡芪ã®é¢å©ãšåã©ãã®æåã®å©çãïŒæ¥åŒé£ãèªç±ãšæ£çŸ©ãïŒ12æå·ïŒ60å·»12å·26é ã䞡芪ã®é¢å©ã»å¥å± ã®éã®é¢äŒäº€æµã®åé¡ç¹ãšèª²é¡ãç¹éïŒã§ãåã®é€è²ãã芪ã®æš©å©ã奪ãããšã¯ïŒïŒäžç¥ïŒâ¡æçè¿œæ±ãåã©ããã奪ãããšã«ãªãã幞çŠè¿œæ±æš©ããããã©ã€ãã·ãŒæš©(èªå·±æ±ºå®æš©)ã䟵害ãšè§£ãããã»ã»ã»ããšåŒçšãïŒãã®å Žåã«
æ¥åŒé£å®¶äºæ³å¶å§å¡äŒäºåå±é·ãè°·è±æš¹åŒè·å£«ã䞡芪ã®é¢å©ãšåã©ãã®æåã®å©çãïŒæ¥åŒé£ãèªç±ãšæ£çŸ©ãïŒ12æå·ïŒ60å·»12å·38é ãé¢äŒäº€æµã®å®åã®åé¡ç¹ãšèª²é¡ãïŒã§ãææèŠå®ããªããšãæš©å©æ§æãã§ããªããšã¯èšããïŒä»è ã®åŠšå®³ãæé€ããŠãå®çŸãã䟡å€ã®ãã芪åã®é¢ä¿ããããäºé ã§ãããšãããšæš©å©æ§æãèªãããããšè§£éããããšã¯å¯èœã»ã»ã»ããšåŒçšããŠç€ºããŠããã
æ³å¶å¯©è°äŒïŒïŒïŒåè°äºé²ïŒé
ãããã£ãšã家äºå¯©å€äºä»¶ã«ãããŸããŠã¯ïŒæªæ幎è ã®å©çïŒå人ã®ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒçãä¿è·ããå¿ èŠãç¹ã«é«ããšããäºæ ãããããŸãã
ããã®ããã«ç€ºããŠãããšããïŒåã®æåã®å©çãåªå ããéçšãæ±ãããã家äºäºä»¶ã«ãããŠïŒæªæ幎è ã®ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒæš©ã¯äººæ ŒçèªåŸæš©ïŒèªå·±æ±ºå®æš©ïŒãšããŠïŒç¶åã®èº«åïŒæ¯åã®èº«åãšåå¥ã«ïŒãããŠå¹³çã«ä¿éãããã¹ãã§ããã
ãåè¿°ã®æåïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒïŒæ¥æé«è£å€æ±º(æå51ïŒãªã328)å€äŸãæ±äº¬å®¶è£å «çåæ¯å¯©å¹³æ18幎1æ31æ¥ïŒå®¶æ58å·»11å·79é ïŒå€äŸãªã©ã®ããã«åã¯èªå·±æ±ºå®ïŒæèŠè¡šæïŒæš©ãæãïŒç¶åé¢ä¿ãšæ¯åé¢ä¿ã¯åå¥ã«ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒã確ä¿ããããã®ã§ããããšã瀺ããŠããã
ããã§åãé£ãå»ã£ãŠå ã«ç£è·ãéå§ããå®è³ªç£è·è ïŒææè ïŒãåãšèŠªãšã®ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒã劚害ãïŒåã®é©æ£æªçœ®è«æ±æš©ïŒç£è·è«æ±æš©ïŒãå¶éããã°ïŒåã芪ãšèŠªåæ§ç¯ïŒèŠªååçµ±åïŒãæ±ããåå¥ã®æš©å©æ§æã«å®³ãåãŒããšã®èŠè§£ãšåèŽããŠããã
ãããã§ç §ããå¿ èŠãããã®ã¯ïŒåã«å¯Ÿããäœçœ°åã³èåŸ ã§ãããé·ç·ã«å¯Ÿããäœçœ°ã¯ãèšãããšãèããªãã®ã§ïŒé ¬ãå©ãããã宿é¡ãããªãã£ãã®ã§ïŒå€ã飯ãäžããªãã£ããããããã ããšå·®å¥çãªæ±ããããããªã©å ç«¥çŠç¥æ³æ¹æ£æ¡ã®ã¬ã€ãã©ã€ã³ãšããŠåçåŽåçãçºè¡šããŠããã
ãèåŸ ã§åœã奪ãããåèçéç°åžã®å°åŠ4幎çæ åå¿æã¡ããã®å©ããä¹ãå人æ å ±ïŒã¢ã³ã±ãŒãïŒã芪暩è ïŒèº«äžç£è·è ïŒã«æŒæŽ©ããããšã§å ç«¥ã®ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒæš©äŸµå®³ãåé¡ãšãªã£ãŠããããšã¯èšæ¶ã«æ°ãããã€ãŸãæ§ã ãªçç±ãããšã«è²ã ãšæèŠãè¡šæãããå人çãªããšãåèªèº«ãã誰ã«äŒããã®ããã«ã€ããŠïŒèªå·±æ±ºå®ïŒæèŠè¡šæïŒããæš©å©ã¯å¹Žéœ¢ã«åãããã«å°éãããªããã°ãªããªãã
ãå®åç·çãåœäŒã§çåŒãããšãããåã©ãããèŠãã°ïŒãç¶ããã«ãäŒãããïŒãæ¯ããã«ãäŒããããšæãããšã¯ãã£ãšãã§ããïŒèŠªãšèªç±ã«äŒããããšåžæããããšã¯åœç¶ãã§ãããåã®ææã«ã¯çç±ããã£ãŠïŒãã®ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒã¯ç¶åé¢ä¿ïŒæ¯åé¢ä¿å ±ã«åå¥ã«å®ãããã¹ããã®ã§ããããïŒèåŸ ãé²ãããã«ãåã®ææãæ°æã¡ããã©ã€ãã·ãŒã®ä¿è·ããã£ãŠå°éãã¹ãåççãªçç±ããã£ãŠïŒéé²ã«ç¡èŠã§ããã¯ãããªãã
ãå ç«¥ã®æš©å©æ¡çŽïŒæ¡ïŒé ãïŒïŒæ¡ãç §ãããŠãïŒæªæ幎ã®æéã¯æé·çºé段éã«ãããšããå®çŸ©ããèãããšïŒåã©ãã«ã¯èªå·±æ±ºå®æš©ïŒãã©ã€ãã·ãŒæš©ïŒèªäœãä¿éãããã¹ãã§ãããïŒèªå·±æ±ºå®ã®å€æèœåãé€ãäžã§ãæèŠè¡šææš©ãäžããããããšãããéèŠãšãããã
ãããã§åãç£è·è ããäœçœ°ãèåŸ ãææãã粟ç¥çè² æ ãçããéã«ïŒæé·éçšã§å®³ãšãªãããç·æ¥ã®äºæ ãç¶èŠªæãã¯æ¯èŠªïŒæãã¯å¥ã®è¿èŠªè ãåŠæ ¡ã®å çãªã©ã«èªãã®èªç±ææã§æèŠè¡šæãããšãã£ãïŒèåŸ èŠªã®äŸåããäººæ ŒçèªåŸãç®æãããšãæå¹ã§ããïŒèŠªãšã®èŠªåæ§ç¯ïŒèŠªååçµ±åïŒã®çºã«ïŒåããã©ã€ãã·ãŒã確ä¿ããªããèªãææžãæ±ããããšãã§ãããšããæèŠè¡šæã®æš©å©ã¯åŠšããããªãã
ãã€ãŸã芪åã®èªç¶æš©ãä¿éããäžã§ïŒæ°æ³ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ã«ã€ããŠã¯åã粟ç¥çã«ã±ã¢ããïŒæãã¯å ç«¥èåŸ ãé²ãäžæ¹æ³ãšããŠéçšãè¡ãããŠãããšã解ãããã®ã§ãããæ®æŽïŒã©ã¡ããäžæ¹ã®èŠªæš©ãå¥å¥ªãããéã«ïŒèŠªæš©ãå¥å¥ªããã芪å¯ãªçŽç³»è¡æã¯åã®å人æ å ±ã®é瀺ãæ±ããæš©å©ãæé€ããïŒåã芪暩è ããèåŸ ãããŠããåãå©ããããšãåºæ¥ãªããšãã£ãéçšããããŠããªãããšããïŒåœäŒè°å¡ã®äžäœçºãç §ããããŠãããšããããã®ã§ããã
ããã§ïŒåã®èªç±ææã®ç¢ºèªã¯å¹Žéœ¢ãå®ããã¹ãã§ã¯ãªãïŒãŸãè«æ±æš©ã«ã€ãïŒãã®æš©å©ã¯å¹Žéœ¢ã«ãã£ãŠå¶éãåããã¹ãã§ã¯ãªãã
ãçµèª
ãé¢äŒäº€æµãäºç¹ãšãªã調åäºä»¶ã®å®æ åã³å¯©çã®åšãæ¹/现ç¢éå€äº. é²è€åçµµå€äº. éç°è£å調æ»å®.å®®åŽè£å調æ»å®ïŒå®¶åºè£å€æå ±64(7)1-97ïŒ 2012-07ïŒ
ããæ±äº¬å®¶è£ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒä»¥äžïŒæ°æ³766æ¡çïŒãèžãŸãïŒåã®çŠç¥ã®èŠ³ç¹ããé¢äŒäº€æµãçŠæ¢ã»å¶éãã¹ãäºç±ãèªããããªãéãïŒäžç¥ïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã®åæ»ãªå®æœã«åããŠå¯©çã»èª¿æŽãé²ããããšãåºæ¬æ¹éãšããŠããïŒäžç¥ïŒãã®ãããªé¢äŒäº€æµäºä»¶ã®å¯©çã«é¢ããåºæ¬æ¹éã¯ïŒçŸåšã®å®¶åºè£å€æã®å®åã«ãããŠåºãå ±æãããŠããã»ã»ã»ã
ããŸãïŒèŠªåãåé¢ããããäºæ ãšããŠ
é¢äŒäº€æµãäºç¹ãšãªã調åäºä»¶ã®å®æ åã³å¯©çã®åšãæ¹/现ç¢éå€äº. é²è€åçµµå€äº. éç°è£å調æ»å®.å®®åŽè£å調æ»å®ïŒå®¶åºè£å€æå ±64(7)1-97ïŒ 2012-07ïŒ
ã¢ïŒéç£è·èŠªã«ããåã®é£ãå»ãïŒç§åã®è¡äœ¿æãã¯èªåææžïŒã®ããã
ã€ïŒéç£è·èŠªã«ããåã®èåŸ ã®ãããç
ãŠïŒéç£è·èŠªã®ç£è·èŠªã«å¯ŸããæŽåç
ãšïŒåã®æ絶
ãªïŒç£è·èŠªåã¯éç£è·èŠªã®åå©ç
ããããæããããŠãããããã§åã®åœ±é¿ãæ€èšããã°
ã¢ïŒããããå ã«ç£è·ãéå§ãã芪ã«å¯ŸããŠçžæ芪ã®èŠªæš©è¡äœ¿åŠšå®³ãç£è·æš©åŠšå®³ããã£ããè©äŸ¡ããŠæ¿«çšã«ã€ãåçççç±ã瀺ããŠèº«äžç£è·æš©ã芪暩ãæž¡ããªããšãã£ãéçšãäžè¬çãšãªãã°ïŒé£ãæ»ãïŒç§åã®è¡äœ¿æãã¯èªåææžïŒã¯æžå°ããã
ãã€ïŒããããå ã«ç£è·ãéå§ãã芪ããèè€ã«ãã£ãŠåã®æš©å©ãå¶éããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒåã®ç²Ÿç¥çè² æ ã粟ç¥çèåŸ ãšããŠå€§ããè©äŸ¡ããéçšãäžè¬çãšãªãã°ïŒåãžã®æ¯é ãç·©ãã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒèåŸ ã®æãã¯å€§ããæžå°ãããã
ããŠïŒé å¶è æŽåã¯ïŒçåœã«é¢ããèšåã®äºå®ãæ€èšŒããå¶åºŠãæªçã§ãããããããå ã«ç£è·ãéå§ãã芪ã¯å©Šäººçžè«æïŒå¥³æ§æ¯æŽã»ã³ã¿ãŒïŒãªã©ã§ïŒ€ïŒ¶ãçžè«ããã ãã®å®çžŸãããšã«äœæç§å¿ããŠåãé£ãå»ãïŒå ã«ç£è·ãéå§ãããïŒçžè«èšŒæã¯çžè«ãããã ãã®èšŒæã§ãã£ãŠïŒçåœãè ããèšåã®äºå®ããã£ãããšãæ€èšŒåã³èšŒæãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã
å¹³æ30幎4æ25æ¥åå€å±å°æ¹è£å€æå€æ±ºã§çŠç°è£å€é·ã¯
ã被害è ã®æ¯æŽå¶åºŠãïŒçžæ芪ãšåäŸã®é¢ä¿ã絶ã€ããã®æ段ãšããŠæªçšãããäºäŸãåé¡åããŠãããåŒå®³ã®å€ãçŸè¡å¶åºŠã¯æ¹åãããã¹ãã ã
ãšèšåãïŒèåœïŒ€ïŒ¶ã«å¯Ÿãã蚎èšã¯åå¥äºäŸã§ã¯ãªããšãïŒå¶åºŠèŠçŽããæ±ããããã®åŸïŒèåœïŒ€ïŒ¶ãç¥ããªããäœæç§å¿ããåç°åžã«æå®³è³ å責任ããããšããŠïŒåç°åžã¯å解å§åã«å¿ããŠèåœïŒ€ïŒ¶ã«ããäœæç§å¿ã®åçãè¬çœªããã
ããã§å®¶ææ³ç 究äŒã¯ïŒæ¯éïŒãã®åé¡ã®å®æ ãçŽèŠãïŒïŒïŒã¢ã«ã瀺ãããïŒçã®ïŒ€ïŒ¶è¢«å®³è ãå®ãããã®ïŒ€ïŒ¶é²æ¢æ³ã«ãããŠïŒèåœïŒ€ïŒ¶ãé²æ¢ãæšèªå®åã®æ¹æ£ãïŒæ€èšŒçŸ©åã«åºã¥ãéçšæ¹åãæ©æã«è¡ãããïŒå®¶ææ³ã«å«ããŠæ€èšããŠé ãããã
ããšïŒåã®æ絶ã«ã€ããŠã¯èº«äžç£è·è ã粟ç¥çã±ã¢ããïŒå»çãã°ã¬ã¯ããè¡ãããŠããªããïŒåã®æš©å©ã䟵害ãããŠããªãããïŒæ°çå§å¡ãªã©ããã§ãã¯ããæ©èœãå¢ããããšãæå¹ã§ããïŒäžçã§ã¯ïŒãã®ãããªæ©èœãåãå ¥ããŠããåœãããã
ãªïŒå ±å芪暩äžã§ããã°ïŒå¯Ÿè±¡ãšãªããªããïŒé¢å©åŸã®ä¿äºã«ã¯åã®èªç±ææã«ã€ãååé æ ®ãå¿ èŠã§ãããç¶ç¶ãç¶æ¯ããã®èåŸ ãåŸã ã«ããŠç®ç«ã€ããšããïŒåã©ãã®æç¶ã代ç人ãåã®å©çïŒæš©å©ïŒåŽã«ç«ã£ãŠèšçœ®ãããå¶åºŠã«ãã¹ãã§ããçŸåšã¯è£å€å®ãéžä»»ããªãã£ããïŒéžä»»ãããŠãåŒè·å£«ãèŸéããããšææ§ãªå¶åºŠãšãªã£ãŠãããïŒïŒæ³æªæºã®æªæ幎åãã代ç人ãä»ããæš©å©ãæé€ããã°åã®æš©å©ä¿éã«åããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒæ³çææžå¶åºŠãšããŠåã©ãã®æç¶ã代ç人ãå¿ ãèšçœ®ããå¶åºŠã«ãã¹ãã§ãããã
é¢äŒäº€æµãäºç¹ãšãªã調åäºä»¶ã®å®æ åã³å¯©çã®åšãæ¹/现ç¢éå€äº. é²è€åçµµå€äº. éç°è£å調æ»å®.å®®åŽè£å調æ»å®ïŒå®¶åºè£å€æå ±64(7)1-97ïŒ 2012-07ïŒ
ããªãïŒéç£è·èŠªã«ãããšãã£ãäºæ ããªããŠãïŒç£è·èŠªãéç£è·èŠªã«å¯Ÿãã粟ç¥çèè€ãææ çåçºçããé¢äŒäº€æµã æåŠããäºäŸãèŠããïŒç¬¬3ç« ã§èŠãããã«ïŒãã€ãŠã¯ïŒãã®ãããªå Žåã«ãããé¢äŒäº€æµã®å®æœã«æ éãªèŠè§£ãèŠããããšããã§ãããããããªããïŒãããŸã§ã«èŠãŠãããããªåã®çŠ ç¥ã®èŠ³ç¹ããã®é¢äŒäº€æµã®éèŠæ§çã«éã¿ãã°ïŒéç£è·èŠªã«ããæåŠèªäœãçç±ãšããŠé¢äŒäº€æµãçŠæ¢ã»å¶éãã¹ãäºç±ããããšèªããããšã¯çžåœã§ãªããšæããããå ·äœçãªäºæ¡ã«ãããŠïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã®å®æœãåã«ã©ã®ãããªåœ±é¿ãåãŒãããšã«ãªãã®ãïŒå®è³ªçãªæ€èšãå¿ èŠã§ããããã
ãã€ãŸãåã®èªç±ææã«ããæèŠè¡šæãèªå·±æ±ºå®ã®æš©å©ãä¿éããçºã«ïŒåã®è«æ±ãå®è³ªçã«æ€èšãïŒãã®è«æ±ã«åœããïŒèŠªã代çè«æ±ãã¹ããïŒç¹å¥ä»£ç人ãéžä»»ãã¹ããããšãã£ãè©äŸ¡ãè£å€å®ã«èª²ããããã®ã§ããã°ïŒæ³çææžå¶åºŠãšããŠåã©ãã®æç¶ã代ç人ãå¿ ãèšçœ®ããå¶åºŠã«ãã¹ãã§ããã
ãå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒïŒæïŒïŒæ¥æ±äº¬é«è£æ±ºå®ïŒå¹³æïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒã©ïŒç¬¬ïŒïŒïŒïŒå·ïŒ
ããåååã³è¢«åãã¯ããããïŒãŸãïŒå€«åã¯åŠ»ãšããŠã®ãäºãã«å¯Ÿããæµå¯Ÿææ ã¯ã²ãšãŸãæªããŠïŒãäºãã«çžæãæªæ幎è ã®æ¯èŠªã§ããïŒç¶èŠªã§ããããšãæ¹ããŠèªèãïŒæªæ幎è ã®ããã«ãã®é床ã§ã¯ãäºããèªãåãïŒãã®ããšãæªæ幎è ãèã§æããŠïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã«å¯Ÿãã粟ç¥çãªå®å¿æãåŸãããããåªåããããšãèèŠã§ãããåœè£å€æã¯ïŒãã®ãããªèãã«ç«ã¡ïŒäžèšã®ãšããïŒååã被åããïŒãäºãã«æªæ幎è ã®ããã«ææ ¢ãïŒååããŠïŒ2åã«1åã¯è¢«åããååžããäžã§ååãšæªæ幎è ãšã®3人ã§ã®é¢äŒäº€æµãå®æœãïŒæªæ幎è ã®ããã®é¢äŒäº€æµã§ããããšããäºãã«åèªèããŠïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã«å¯Ÿããä¿¡é Œé¢ä¿ã確ç«ãã¹ãã§ãããšèãããã
ããã®ããã«ç€ºããŠããã芪暩ã®äžã§ïŒãã®èº«äžç£è·æš©ã®ã¿ãåãåºããŠïŒèŠªãåã©ããç£è·ãæè²ããæš©å©çŸ©åããç£è·æš©ããšåŒãã§ããå®åããããïŒç£è·æš©ãšã¯ïŒåã©ãã®äžè©±ãæè²ãéããŠæãã¬ããããäŒãã芪ã®æš©å©çŸ©åã§ãããç¶æ§åçç¿åŸåã³æ¯æ§åçç¿åŸïŒäž¡èŠªããå¹³çã«åããæè²ãæè²ã«æ¬ ãããšãããããã°å¿çã±ã¢ãæœãïŒåã®å©çã害ããããšããªããã責任ãçãããã®ã§ãããè£å€äžã®é¢å©ã®å Žåã«ã¯ïŒç¶æ¯ã®äžæ¹ãäžåçã«èŠªæš©è ãšå®ããèŠå®ãååšãããïŒç£è·ã®å ±åæš©å©è ã®ïŒã©ã¡ããäžæ¹èŠªããå šç£è·æš©ã奪åãã¹ãå Žåã¯ïŒåã«å¯Ÿãã害ãæããã§ããå Žåã«éå®ãããã®ã§ããã
ãïŒïŒã¢ã§ç€ºããæé«è£å€äŸã«ããã°ïŒå ±å芪暩äžã®å¥å± 芪ãïŒé¢å©ããŠé芪暩è ãšãªãå¥å± 芪ãïŒåã®ç£è·ãæ ãæš©å©è ã§ããç¶ãããšããŠæ瀺ããŠããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒã€ãŸãç£è·è ã®æå®ã¯ïŒèº«äžç£è·è ã®æå®ã§ããããããå ±å芪暩äžã«å± ææå®ãç§åã§æ±ºå®ãïŒå ±å芪暩äžã«èªåææžã§å ã«ç£è·ãéå§ããŠå®è³ªç£è·è ãšãªãïŒå¥å± 芪ã«æããïŒèº«äžç£è·æš©ä»¥å€ã®ç£è·ããæš©å©ãç§åã§åŠšããããšã¯åã®æææ¯é ã§ããïŒäžæ³ïŒéæ³ïŒè¡çºã§ããããšãææããéæ³æ§ãè©äŸ¡ãããªããã°ãªããªãã
ãã€ãŸãæªæ幎åã䞡芪ã®ååšãèã§æããŠïŒç²Ÿç¥çãªå®å¿æãåŸãããããšãïŒåã®å¥å šãªçºéã«è²¢ç®ããåã®å©çã§ããïŒåã®å©çã«æ¬ ãããšãããããã°åã«ç²Ÿç¥çè² æ ã倧ããçãããšããããšã¯ïŒäžèšããç解ããã¹ãã§ããããã®é床ãè¶ ãããšåã«ç²Ÿç¥ççŸæ£ãçããæžå¿µãæããŠãããïŒç²Ÿç¥çèåŸ ãšãªãããã®ã§ããããïŒä»®ã«èè€ããããããšããçç±ã§ïŒèªåææžãæææ¯é ã«å¯ŸããŠéæ³æ§ãè©äŸ¡ããªãããšã¯ïŒãããã倱åœãªã®ã§ããã
ãç·åã¯å¥å± 芪ã§ããç¶èŠªãšãã£ããããŒã«ãäžåºŠãåºæ¥ãªããšãïŒå¥³åãå¥å± 芪ã§ããæ¯èŠªãšäžç·ã«ãã¬ãŒã³ããªã©è²·ãã«è¡ã£ãããšããªããªã©ïŒæãã¯ä¹³å ãæ¯èŠªããæ¯ä¹³ã飲ãããšãèš±ãããªããªã©ïŒäž¡èŠªãçŽäºããã°ïŒã»ãšãã©ã®åã芪ãšåé¢ã匷èŠãããŠãããé«æ ¡çã«ãªãïŒïŒæ³çšåºŠãŸã§ã®ææã«ããïŒç¶æ§åçãšæ¯æ§ååã®äž¡æ¹ãå¹³çã«ç¿åŸãã¹ãåã®å©çïŒæš©å©ïŒãããïŒæ¯ä¹³ã飲ãæš©å©ã飲ãŸããæ¯èŠªã®æš©å©ã¯ïŒæ¯åé¢ä¿ã®æé·éçšã«æ¬ ãããªãç¹ã«éèŠãªææã§ãã£ãŠïŒå¥å šãªçºéãä¿éãããæè²ãé€è²ã®äžç«¯ã§ããã
ãããã§ä¿éãããã¹ãåã®é©æ£æªçœ®è«æ±æš©ïŒç£è·è«æ±æš©ïŒããéã¿ãŠãïŒå ±å芪暩äžã®å€«å©Šã§ããã°å¥å± 芪ã®èŠªæš©è¡äœ¿ã劚害ãããŠããã®ã§ããããïŒé©æ£æªçœ®ãæ±ããã«ãããïŒä»æ¹èŠªãåã©ãã®æç¶ã代ç人ãèšçœ®ãããªã©ãåã®ä»£çæš©è ãšããŠïŒèŠªæš©è¡äœ¿ã®åŠšå®³æé€ãæ±ããããšã劥åœã§ããã
ïŒã®ã¢ã«ç€ºãããé¢æ¥äº€æžãšåŒ·å¶å·è¡ã(å€äŸã¿ã€ã 㺠1087å·42é )ã®åŒçšããéã¿ãã°ïŒå ã«ç£è·ãéå§ããŠç£è·è ã䞻匵ããã®ã§ããã°ïŒåã®å¿èº«ã«äžèªç±ã匷èŠããã®ã§ã¯ãªãïŒåã®è¡ããããšããã«è¡ãããšã«ã€ããµããŒããïŒéä¿¡ãæããªãã°ïŒå¿ççã±ã¢ãæœããŠïŒåºæ¥ãéãå¯èœãªéä¿¡ããããããµããŒãåºæ¥ãé©ä»»è ãšããŠïŒåã®å¿èº«ãã±ã¢ãã¹ãã§ããïŒãŸãïŒãã®äž»åŒµããã¹ããã®ãšã解ããã®ã§ããã
ããšããã§ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒæš©ïŒèªå·±æ±ºå®æš©ïŒã¯ïŒåã®é©æ£æªçœ®è«æ±æš©ïŒç£è·è«æ±æš©ïŒã«äžé£ã§ïŒå ±ã«è©äŸ¡ãããã¹ãã§ãããåãæ¯èŠªãšç¶èŠªãšåå¥ã«ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒã確ä¿ãïŒèªç±ææã®å ã«æèŠè¡šæã§ããæš©å©ãæããã®ã§ããããïŒèŠªåã®èº«åãåå¥ã«ä¿éããã°ïŒå¿ççã±ã¢ã«æ¬ ãããšãããããã°ïŒãã®è£å¡«ãåºæ¥ïŒèåŸ ãããã°ææžã§ãããšãããã®ã§ããã
ãåã®æåã®å©çïŒæš©å©ïŒãä¿éãã¹ãïŒåã®èº«æã¯ïŒããããææããéæŸãïŒå ã®ç£è·å°ãžæ»ããããã§ããŸããŸãªæ³çæªçœ®ãè¬ããã¹ãã§ãããèªåææžè¡çºãåãææããè¡çºãïŒåŒè·å£«ãæåïŒæãã¯æåãããïŒå©é·ããŠããçŸç¶ããã£ãŠïŒæããã«åã®çŠç¥ãå©çïŒæš©å©ïŒã«å®³ãåãŒããŠããã
ãã€ãŸããšããåãç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒã«ãã£ãŠé£ãå»ãïŒå ã«ç£è·ããã°æåã§ãã£ãŠïŒææã®ç¶ç¶æ§ããè»çŠãè©äŸ¡ãããããåã®å¿ççè² æ ãèæ ®ããŠãïŒåã®å¿èº«ã¯çŽã¡ã«éæŸããå ã®ç£è·å°ã«æ»ããŠèªç±ã確ä¿ããïŒãã®åŸã«æ³çæªçœ®ãè¬ããã¹ãã§ãããã
ãããã§åã®å®è³ªç£è·è æãã¯ãã®è£å©è ã䞻匵ããã®ã§ããã°ïŒåã®èº«æãèªç±ã«éæŸããäºããïŒèŠªãšåã®èªç¶æš©ãå°éããããšã§ããïŒåã®çŠç¥ã®èŠ³ç¹ã«ç«ã£ãŠä¿¡é Œé¢ä¿ã確ç«ããŠããããšãæãŸããã®ã¯ãããŸã§ããªããåã®çŠç¥ã«æ²¿ããã®ã§ããïŒããã¯æªæ幎åã®å¹Žéœ¢ãåããã«ïŒåã®å©çïŒæš©å©ïŒãä¿éãããšãããã®ã§ããã
ãã€ãŸãåã®è«æ±æš©ã«ã€ãèªå·±æ±ºå®ã®è©äŸ¡åºæºãïŒïŒæãšããŠèšããã¹ãã§ã¯ãªããšããïŒå¹Žéœ¢ã«é¢ãããæš©å©ãä¿éããããåçççç±ãããã
ãç·æ¬
ãããã«ããåã©ãã®æç¶ã代ç人ã矩ååãããªã©ä¿é²ããŠæ¡å ãã¹ãã§ãããé¢å©å±ã«é€è²è²»ãšé¢äŒäº€æµã®ãã§ãã¯æ¬ããããïŒåããã倫婊ãšåããªã倫婊ãåãåçæ¹æ³ã§ããããšãåé¡ã§ãããåããã倫婊ã®å Žåã«ã¯ïŒãã®çåœãå¥å šãªçºéãå®ããã矩åãšè²¬ä»»ãçããå¥çŽãšé²åããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒããããå§ä»»å¥çŽã§ã¯ãªãã®ã§ããããïŒãã€ã§ã解é€ã§ãããšããæ°æ³ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ã«é¡æšïŒæãã¯æºçšåºæ¥ãã¯ãããªããå©å§»å¥çŽã®è§£é€ãåè°ã«ä»»ããããšãæ¬æ¥ïŒèªããã¹ããåŠããéèŠãªæ€èšèª²é¡ã§ããã家åºã®åé¡ãšããŠããããã«ä»å ¥åºæ¥ãªããšããã°ïŒæ¥æ¬ã®èª¿åå眮䞻矩ããããã ã®ããã«ïŒåã®èª¿åå眮èŠå®ãšããŠçŸ©ååããŠïŒãã®åŸã®åã®ç£è·ç¶æ³ãæ°çå§å¡ãªã©ãå ¬çã«ãã§ãã¯ããå¶åºŠãèšçœ®ããããšãåã®å¥å šãªçºéãå®ãäžã§ã¯æå¹ãšèšããã®ã§ããã
殺åŠåãŒãã«åããŠããããåŒãåãä¿è·äž»ã«å¯Ÿãã远跡調æ»ãæ°éæ¯æŽå£äœãè¡ã£ãŠããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒäººéã®åã«å¯ŸããŠïŒèåŸ ãé²æ¢ãã芳ç¹ãã远跡調æ»ãã¹ãã§ã¯ãªããšããåçççç±ã¯ç¡ãã家åºãžã®ä»å ¥ã¯å¥å šãªå®¶åºã§ããã°åé¡ã§ãããïŒäŸãã°æ§ç¯çœªè ã¯å床åãç¯çœªãè¡ããªã¹ã¯ãé«ã远跡調æ»ãæ€èšãããŠããããšãšåããïŒç¶ç¶ã«ããæ§ç¯çœªãæ€èšããã°ïŒè¿œè·¡èª¿æ»ãåŠå®ãããªãã®ã§ãããæ°çå§å¡ãèŠä¿è·å 童察çå§å¡äŒã®çŽäžãšããŠé£æºããã°ïŒåžåœ¹æ家åºç§ãæè²å§å¡äŒïŒå ç«¥çžè«æãèŠå¯ãšé£æºããããšãšãªãããŸãæ°çå§å¡ã®å·¡åå§èšäºæ¥ãšããŠåéããŠïŒé¢äŒäº€æµæ¯æŽãªã©ãè¡ã£ãŠãããªã©å£äœãåãæã€ããšã®åºæ¥ãå¶åºŠãæ€èšãã¹ãã§ããã
åã©ãã®æç¶ã代ç人ãšã¯ïŒå®¶äºäºä»¶æç¶æ³ïŒïŒæ¡ïŒé ïŒåæ³ïŒïŒæ¡ïŒé ïŒåæ³ïŒïŒïŒæ¡ïŒåæ³ïŒïŒïŒå·ïŒé ã«åºã¥ãïŒè·æš©ã§æç¶ã代ç人ãéžä»»ãïŒïŒïŒæ¡ïŒé ïŒåïŒïŒæ¡ïŒé ã«åºã¥ãïŒåã©ããæ¬æç¶ãã«è·æš©ã§åå ãããããšãã§ããã
家äºäºä»¶æç¶æ³23æ¡1é åã¯2é ã«ããè£å€é·ãéžä»»ãïŒåã¯éžä»»ãåœããæç¶ä»£ç人(以äžãåã©ãã®æç¶ä»£ç人ããšããã)ã«é¢ãïŒæ¥æ¬åŒè·å£«é£åäŒããåå°ã®åŒè·å£«äŒã«å¯ŸãïŒæžç°¡(å¹³æ27幎8æ21æ¥ä»ããåã©ãã®æç¶ä»£ç人ã®åœ¹å²ãšåå¶åºŠã®å©çšãæçšãªäºæ¡ã®é¡åãã®éä»åã³åšç¥ã«ã€ããŠ(äŸé Œ) ã )ãéä»ããæšã®æ å ±æäŸãæé«è£å€æãåãïŒåæžç°¡ã«æ·»ä»ãããŠãããåã©ãã®æç¶ä»£ç人ã®åœ¹å²ãšåå¶åºŠã®å©çšãæçšãªäºæ¡ã®é¡åããïŒæé«è£å€æãšã®åè°ãèžãŸãïŒãã®å©çšãæ³å®ãããå Žé¢ãæ確ã«ãããŠãããšããŠïŒé©å®ïŒè£å€å®åã³é¢ä¿è·å¡ã«åšç¥ããããã«ïŒå¹³æ27幎8æ24æ¥ã«æé«è£å€æäºåç·å±å®¶åºå±ç¬¬äºèª²é·ããå家åºè£å€æäºåå±é·ã«éç¥ãããŠããå¶åºŠã§ããã
家åºè£å€æ調æ»å®ãšå ±ã«ïŒç£è·èŠªïŒç£è·è£å©è ãå«ïŒã®å± ãªãç°å¢ïŒå°åŠæ ¡ãªã©ïŒã§ç£è·èŠªãžã®äŸåã«ã€ããŠé æ ®ããªããïŒåã©ãã®èªç±ææã芪åæ§ã確èªãïŒåºæ¬ç人暩ãäººæ Œæš©ãå°éãã¹ãæç¶ãã®ä»£çæš©ãæãã代ç人ã§ãã£ãŠïŒæ°æ³766æ¡ãç §ããïŒåã®æš©å©æ§ã«éãã眮ããæ¯æŽå¶åºŠãšããŠè¡ã£ãŠããã
ãããã¯æ¥æ¬åœæ²æ³ïŒïŒæ¡ïŒèœåã«å¿ããŠïŒç¶æ§ååïŒæ¯æ§ååãªã©ã®ç¿åŸãå«ãïŒåã®ã²ãšããæè²ãåããæš©å©ãä¿éãããã®ãšããŠäººæš©ä¿éã®åºæ¬ååãå®ããŠããïŒå ¬å¹³ãªé€è²ïŒæè²ãä¿éããçºã«ïŒå ¬å¹³ãªæè²ãåã©ããåããæš©å©ãšããŠå°éããå¶åºŠãšãããã
ããã§å ç«¥ã®æš©å©æ¡çŽïŒïŒæ¡ãç §ããã°ïŒåã©ããšããŠã¯èªã代ç人ãåŸãæš©å©ãæãïŒæ¬æ¥ïŒåã©ãã®æç¶ã代ç人ãªã©èŠªå士ã®èª¿åïŒé¢å©ïŒé¢äŒäº€æµïŒç£è·è ã®æå®ïŒèŠªæš©åªå€±ã»åæ¢ïŒç®¡çæš©åªå€±ïŒèŠªæš©è ã®æå®ã»å€æŽãªã©ïŒã«å©å®³é¢ä¿äººãšããŠåå ããããšãæå¹ãªã®ã§ãã£ãŠåã¯é©æ£æªçœ®ãè«æ±ããæç¶ããè¡äœ¿ã§ãããã€ãŸãåããæåãããããšã«ã€ããŠïŒåãã¯èªãæå®³è³ åãè«æ±ããããšãã§ãïŒåã«ç¹å¥ä»£ç人ãéžä»»ãã¹ãããšãæ€èšãã¹ãã§ããïŒåã¯å¹Œå°ã®è¡çºèœåã§ã¯èŠªãéžã¹ãªãããšããïŒä»£ç人ãã€ããããšãåºæ¥ãªãã®ã§ããã°éæ²ã§ãããšãããã
ãå ç«¥èåŸ ã®é²æ¢çã«é¢ããæ³åŸ
ã第äžæ¡ãäœäººãïŒå ç«¥ã«å¯ŸãïŒèåŸ ãããŠã¯ãªããªãã
ã第åæ¡
ãïŒãå ç«¥ã®èŠªæš©ãè¡ãè ã¯ïŒå ç«¥ãå¿èº«ãšãã«å¥ããã«è²æããããšã«ã€ããŠç¬¬äžçŸ©ç責任ãæãããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒèŠªæš©ãè¡ãã«åœãã£ãŠã¯ïŒã§ããéãå ç«¥ã®å©çãå°éããããåªããªããã°ãªããªãã
ãïŒãäœäººãïŒå ç«¥ã®å¥å šãªæé·ã®ããã«ïŒè¯å¥œãªå®¶åºçç°å¢åã³è¿é£ç€ŸäŒã®é£åž¯ãæ±ããããŠããããšã«çæããªããã°ãªããªãã
ã第å æ¡ãå ç«¥èåŸ ãåãããšæãããå ç«¥ãçºèŠããè ã¯ïŒéããã«ïŒãããåžçºæïŒéœéåºçã®èšçœ®ããçŠç¥äºåæè¥ããã¯å ç«¥çžè«æåã¯å ç«¥å§å¡ãä»ããŠåžçºæïŒéœéåºçã®èšçœ®ããçŠç¥äºåæè¥ããã¯å ç«¥çžè«æã«éåããªããã°ãªããªãã
ã以äžãéã¿ãã°ïŒåã芪ãšåé¢ã匷èŠãããå Žåã«ïŒå ç«¥çžè«æã«éåããåççãªçç±ãçãããšãããã®ã§ããã
1ïŒèŠªæš©ãè¡ãã«åœãã£ãŠã¯ïŒã§ããéãå ç«¥ã®å©çãå°éããããåªããªããã°ãªããªããããã劚ããã°ïŒèŠªæš©ã®æ¿«çšãç §ããã¹ãã§ããã
2ïŒå ç«¥ã®å¥å šãªæé·ã®ããã«ïŒè¯å¥œãªå®¶åºçç°å¢åã³è¿é£ç€ŸäŒã®é£åž¯ãæ±ããããŠãããåã®èŠ³ç¹ããçæããããç°å¢ãæŽåãã¹ãã§ããã
ããã®ïŒç¹ãç §ããåãããã°ïŒç芪çå€ã®ç°å¢ã«ïŒå ç«¥ã®ç²Ÿç¥ç圱é¿ã¯è² æ ã倧ããïŒåŸã«ç²Ÿç¥çé害ãçããããšå¯èœæ§ãé«ãããšããïŒèŠªãšåãåé¢ããããšïŒåã®èŠ³ç¹ããææãããç°å¢åãšããŠåãžã®ç²Ÿç¥çèåŸ ãšææãããäºæ ããããšè©äŸ¡ã§ããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒããããç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒãåã®å©çïŒæš©å©ïŒã害ãããã®ãšããŠéåããªããã°ãªããªãç¶æ³ãšãªãããšãåŠå®ãããªãã
é¢äŒäº€æµãäºç¹ãšãªã調åäºä»¶ã®å®æ åã³å¯©çã®åšãæ¹/现ç¢éå€äº. é²è€åçµµå€äº. éç°è£å調æ»å®.å®®åŽè£å調æ»å®ïŒå®¶åºè£å€æå ±64(7)1-97ïŒ 2012-07ïŒ
ãåæ¹ã®å¯Ÿå¿ïŒåé¡ç¹ïŒåã®ç¶æ³ãæåçãç確ã«èŽåãïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã®åæ»ãªå®æœã劚ããŠããèŠå ãäœã§ããããææ¡ããããšãèèŠã§ããããããŠïŒäŸãã°ïŒç£è·èŠªãé¢äŒäº€æµã®æ矩ãååç解ããŠããªããšæãããå Žåã¯ïŒãåœäºè å©èšçšïŒ€ïŒ¶ïŒ€ããïŒãªãŒãã¬ãããé¢äŒäº€æµã®ãããäžå®ããã芪åã®äº€æµãç¶ããããã«ãçã掻çšãïŒé¢äŒäº€æµã®æ矩(åã¯ïŒå¥å± åŸãéç£è·èŠªãšç¶ç¶çã«äº€æµãæã€ããšã«ãã£ãŠïŒãããŸã§ãšå€ãããæãããŠãããšå®æããããšãã§ãïŒéç£è·èŠªãšã®é¢å¥ãšããäœéšãä¹ãè¶ããããšãã§ãïŒãããåã®çŠç¥ã®ç¢ºä¿ã«ã€ãªããããš)ãåãããããäžå¯§ã«èª¬æãã¹ãã§ããã
ãŸãïŒç£è·èŠªãé¢äŒäº€æµã®æ矩ãããçšåºŠç解ããŠãããã®ã®ïŒéç£è·èŠªã«å¯Ÿããææ çåçºããé¢äŒäº€æµãæåŠããŠããå Žåã«ã¯ïŒç£è·èŠªã®å¿æ ãåŸèŽãã€ã€ïŒé¢å©çŽäºã«äŒŽãéç£è·èŠªã«å¯Ÿããææ çãªåé¡ãšé¢äŒäº€æµã®åé¡ãšã¯ïŒ åºå¥ãããå¿ èŠãããããšã説æããããšçãèããããã»ã»ã»ã
ããã®ããã«ç€ºãããŠããã芪åäžåé¢ã®ååã¯ç¹æ®µã®çç±ãªããã°èªç¶ã®æš©å©ãšããŠå°éãããã¹ãã§ãããïŒææ çåçºã§ç§åãè¡äœ¿ããŠåãå¶éããããšãé²ãããã«ïŒåã«æããæš©å©ãä¿éãããã¹ãã§ããïŒåã®ä»£ç人ãè«æ±ããæš©éã«ã€ãæé€ãããªãã
ãäžèšä»¥å€ã«ãïŒèŠªåã®åé¢ãåã«å¯ŸããŠç²Ÿç¥çã«å®³ãããããšã瀺ããæç®ãããã
é¢äŒäº€æµãäºç¹ãšãªã調åäºä»¶ã®å®æ åã³å¯©çã®åšãæ¹/现ç¢éå€äº. é²è€åçµµå€äº. éç°è£å調æ»å®.å®®åŽè£å調æ»å®ïŒå®¶åºè£å€æå ±64(7)1-97ïŒ 2012-07ïŒ
é¢å©ãšåã©ãã®çºé
é¢å©ãåã©ããšå®¶æã«åãŒã圱é¿ã«ã€ããŠ
å¥ããŠæ®ããç¶èŠªãšåã©ããšã®é¢äŒäº€æµå®æ 調æ»
ç¶èŠªã®äžåšãåã©ãã«äžãã圱é¿
芪ã®é¢å©ãçµéšããåã©ãã®ç²Ÿç¥çºéã«é¢ããæç®çç 究
芪ã®çŽäºãåã©ãã®çºéã«äžãã圱é¿ïŒïŒ¬ïŒ©ïŒ¢ïŒ²ïŒ¡ïŒïŒïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæå·ïŒ
ãªã©ïŒä»ã«ãå€ã çºè¡šãããŠããã
ãããã®æç®ããããç §ããã¹ãã§ããããŸããŠã芪ã®çŽäºãåã©ãã®çºéã«äžãã圱é¿ïŒã®ãåŒè·å£«ãšããŠã©ãé¢ããã¹ãããã«ã¯ãïŒå¯ŸïŒã®å Žé¢ã§ïŒåã©ãã®æ³ãã¯ç解ããŠããäºïŒäŒãããæ°æã¡ã«ãªãããšãåœç¶ã ãšããäºãäŒããŠããããã®äžã§ãŸãŸãªããªãããšã«å¯ŸããŠã®ãããããªãæ°æã¡ãå ±æã§ããã°è¯ãã»ã»ã»ããšç²Ÿç¥ç§å»ã¯åçããŠããã
åŒè·å£«ïŒ¢ã®è³ªçå¿çã§ã¯ïŒç²Ÿç¥ç§å»ããåã©ãã®åé¡è¡åãèµ·ããããšã«ããåãã瀺ããŠãããããã¯åããè¡šæãããææã®åããšããŠå°éããããèªå·±æ±ºå®ã®æš©å©ã§ãã£ãŠïŒèŠªåã®é¢å¥åé¢ã粟ç¥ç圱é¿ãšãªã£ãŠããããšãåŠå®ãããªãã
ã€ãŸãé芪暩è ã§ãã£ãŠãå ±å芪暩äžã®å¥å± 芪ã§ãã£ãŠãäžåœã«åããã®èŠªãšåé¢ãããããšã«ãã£ãŠïŒåãåãã粟ç¥çãªå®³ãææãããŠããã®ã§ãã£ãŠïŒåã«ãšã£ãŠã¯ç²Ÿç¥çè² æ ã倧ããïŒå°æ¥ã«ãŸã§åœ±é¿ããããšã¯ïŒæèè ã瀺ããŠããæã§ããããè©äŸ¡ãããã¹ãã§ããã
ç§åã®è¡äœ¿ïŒèªåææžïŒã¯å°åºèªãããããã®ã§ã¯ãªããåãé£ãå»ãããšãïŒç¹æ®µã®çç±ãªã芪ãšåé¢ã匷èŠããããšïŒåãææããããšã¯å°åºèªããããªããéè€ãããïŒå®åéŠçžãåœäŒçåŒã§ãåã©ãã®ç®ç·ã§èšãã°ïŒãç¶ããã«ãäŒãããïŒãæ¯ããã«ãäŒããããããæãã®ã¯åœç¶ãã§ãã£ãŠïŒæããã«åã®èªç±ææã«åããŠããŠïŒåã«å¿ççæå§ã課ããŠããŠéé£ã«å€ããã
ãã®ããšãé²ãããã«ã¯ïŒé¢å©ã«ãããå ¬çææžã®çŸ©ååãªã©å¶åºŠã®æ¡å ïŒåã©ãã®ä»£ç人矩ååãªã©å¶åºŠã®æ¡å ãå¿ èŠã§ãããåã®èªç±ææïŒæèŠè¡šæïŒã«ã€ãè©äŸ¡ã«å¹Žéœ¢å¶éãèšããã¹ãã§ã¯ãªãïŒåã®ä»£çæš©ã¯ïŒç£è·ã®è«æ±æš©ã«ããã代çæš©ãšããŠïŒèŠªæš©è 以å€ã®ç£è·ã®æš©å©è ã§ããé芪暩è ã®èŠªãïŒãã®æš©å©ãçžç¶ããã芪å¯ãªçŽç³»è¡æã«èªããå¶åºŠããã確ç«ããŠããã¹ãã§ããã
ãã®ããã§åã®å¹Žéœ¢ã«å¶éãªã芪åãåçµ±åãã¹ãåçççç±ãããïŒåã®å¹Žéœ¢ã«å¶éãªãçŽã¡ã«ææããéæŸãæ±ããããšãã§ãïŒåã®å¹Žéœ¢ã«å¶éãªãåã®å©çã«è³ããç£è·ãæ±ããããã«ã¯é©æ£æªçœ®ïŒåŠšå®³æé€ïŒãè«æ±ã§ãããã®ã§ãªããã°ãªããªãã
以äžãæèŠããã
åèãæ¥æ¬åŒè·å£«é£åäŒå®¶äºæ³å¶å§å¡äŒç·šã家äºäºä»¶ã«ãããåã©ãã®å°äœ ãåã©ã代ç人ããèããâãïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒæïŒæ¥æ¬å é€åºçïŒ